"Every psychological theory, apart from what it achieves from the point of view of natural science, must fulfill yet another major requirement. It should explain to us what we are aware of, in the most puzzling fashion, through our 'consciousness' and, since this consciousness knows nothing of what we have so far been assuming - quantities and neurones - it should explain this lack of knowledge to us as well." Freud, S.(1897). Standard Edition, Vol 1, ‘The Project for a Scientific Psychology', section [7] 'The Problem of Quality'.
Before I get into the issue associated with this blog, I have to first share my premise.
Freud originally began as a neurologist and initially proposed many advanced ideas about the neural underpinnings of certain mental states, and that’s why I’m certain that we live within potential, and to what extent the plasticity of the brain has an impact on the mind, and “vice versa” (Latin: the other way around).
I believe that it won’t be much of a surprise for many of my readers to figure out that I’m an Aristotelian with a deep appreciation of St. Sigmund Freud (not the current American interpretation, but by reading “raw” Freud), yes, I know, I just canonized him. Because of this, I’m a passionate lover of hermeneutics, heuristics and phenomenology.
Hermeneutics: The art, skill, or theory of understanding and classifying meaning. It is often applied to the interpretation of human actions, utterances, products, and institutions. A hermeneutic interpretation requires the individual to understand and sympathize with another person's point of view: empathy. In Greek a hermeneus was an interpreter and the word probably originates from the name of Hermes, messenger of the gods and epitome of eloquence. In its current uses and definitions hermeneutics was agreed to be the art and science of interpretation, primarily, though not exclusively, of religious texts, and now it’s widely used within the Social Sciences. A more specific implication was that hermeneutics was concerned with real and hidden meanings, quite different from the elucidation and concern with practical application which was the concern of exegesis.
Heuristics: I’m a firm believer that a richer educational method in which learning takes place through discoveries that result from investigations made by the student have a deeper and longer impact upon the researcher’s mind
Phenomenologist: I have discovered that this philosophy or method of inquiry, as based upon the premise that reality consists of objects and events as they are perceived or understood in human consciousness and not of anything independent of human consciousness, has the potential to further lead us toward a deeper comprehension of the Human experience. I also admit that I’m having a love affair with Edmund Husserl (1905).
Consequently, when a friend accused me of “having rigid boundaries” because
(a) I would not allow him to know the intricate details of another person’s life
(b) I won’t allow him to come over to consume mass volumes and quantities of my booze, food, and time, while under the guise of “playing a board game”, hey, I’m poor, things are financially tight over here
(c) I will not allow him to take whatever he wants at any given hour, from my home (and he doesn’t return what he takes)
(d) he cannot use me as his personal neuropsychoanalyst without expecting me to send him a bill, as I would expect him to do with me if I were to seek out his medical professional skills
So, I had to congratulate him on having the ability to at least perceive that his concept of “friendship” is based predominantly upon stealing and violating.
As a result, we engaged in the following questions: what is a friend? What is friendship?
I know that there have been volumes written on these two subjects and I don’t want to write another book, or several, but I am going to share just a few of my insights.
My Premise:
I believe that if we don’t have an accurate and mutual definition of something within a social context, and a shared comprehension, then chaos will follow, thank you Aristotle:
"If a word has an infinite number of meanings, obviously reasoning would be impossible; for not to have one meaning is to have no meaning, and if words have no meaning our reasoning with one another has been annihilated."
Aristotle, Metaphysica Book IV
Here's how a farmer used Aristotle's quote to teach his son the importance of proper definitions for understanding.
A farmer asked his son, "Steve, how many legs has a horse?"
"Four", his son replied.
"Correct", said the father.
Then the farmer continued in the manner of Socrates.
"Now if we call the horse's tail a leg, then how many legs does the horse have?" the father asked.
"Five", his son answered.
"You're wrong, Steve", his father told him (in no uncertain terms), and then the farmer went on to say, “The horse has only four legs. Just because we call the tail a leg that does not turn the tail into a leg."
And just because something is dubbed as "friendship", that doesn't make it so!
My Argument
I understand that within all Human relationships there are degrees of familiarity ranging from deep psychological intimacy that can only occur between you and one person, to the other and often opposite extremes of: usury, detachment, psychological disassociation, reward/punishment, and/or indifference. For my friend, and let’s call him Steve, the issue of “what is a friend” and “what constitutes friendship” is related to “vagueness”. Steve isn’t aware that “vagueness” is his value especially as associated with friendship.
Steve and I agree that within friendships there are some sense of fuzzy or indeterminate demarcations like one might see within an impressionist art painting that seems to elude the idealized notion of a sharply bounded object, but he doesn’t understand that deep and real friendship, if it is to be healthy and nurturing, then it will require a focused mind upon that which is good, uplifting, appreciative and validating.
Therein is the crisis, his unfocused mind toward what is nurturing is an issue, and when he is focused, it is not upon what is good rather he is only focused upon: what’s in it for “him”, or how can he use you. He is ignorant of that which is good, and he values his ignorance of what constitutes a healthy mental hygiene and so he is vague about the boundaries of a healthy friendship because that “vagueness” allows him to get away with nearly any kind of an abuse. As Aristotle would suggest: ignorance is the opposite of wisdom. Unfortunately, the various “Steves” in our lives do not value wisdom.
I have a problem, because his “fuzziness”, within relationships is ignorant of healthy boundaries, and he doesn’t appreciate that the awareness of boundaries are necessary. It’s like saying, he doesn’t want to know, or he doesn’t care to know, where “he” ends, and “you” begin. He’s fuzzy, vague, and blurred about those boundaries because it's always about "him" and his chaos.
Regarding healthy boundaries, I would say to Steve, for example:
-you are not my spouse, and when I’m showering you may not come into the bathroom to have a conversation or brush your teeth unless I invite you and then “that” will become a welcoming habit between you and I rather than a violation of my boundaries because his behaviors are based upon my invitation
-while I’m pooping, you may not sit beside me to discuss Freud, or the latest events of your day
-that’s my article, car, skillet, television, computer, pair of pants, and no, you may not just walk in and take it
-it’s my time to do what I please, it might be to study, work, rest, or play, and no, you may not impose yourself and distract me from my goal for your own amusement or distraction
Perhaps a more concrete example could be applied regarding Steve’s “vagueness” and his violation of boundaries, so I’ll use a metaphor.
You might be at the bottom of Mt. Everest and ignorant of its height and dimensions, but there is no vague boundary to this mountain rather there are distinct properties that you may and may not see, regardless of your respect or lack thereof, while flying your plane if you don’t respect those properties, and if you value ignorance then you will crash and die upon flying into the mountain. Also, there is the potential of killing others due to your ignorance of boundaries.
I love Aristotle because accurate definitions of words and concepts will accomplish much good and prevent chaos, especially when two people are working toward a healthy relationship and friendship by showing how several things related to the same general category differ from each other. As the story illustrates, to show how a horse's leg differs from its tail, is the same as to show how a human mammal differs from a non-human mammal and to show how friendship differs from usury, exploitation, and how ignorance encourages crashing into the other whereas wisdom allows one to have a regard, and respect for the “other”.
Were there no agreed upon meanings for words then Aristotle’s quote is quite right, there would be chaos because people would not be able to reason with each other or share concepts. And, from my professional experiences in clinical case studies, chaos exists in some forms of schizophrenia where words are strictly private matters and only understood by the patient but not understood by anyone else.
Therefore if you have a social unit that has a closed system of understanding words and behaviors, then that is identical to social-schizophrenia, and it’s also known as tribalism, where out-group members are harmed due to the in-group value of being closed hence chaos within any social setting because the words and behaviors are only understood and accepted from within the smaller social unit.
May God help the out-group person who attempts to reason with the in-group member because reasonableness hence love would not be possible.
Let’s not forget that there are other mental, neurological and psychological states, other than individual and social schizophrenia, that will make it almost impossible to have a friendship with someone who who is habituated with an in-group mentality. By definition alone, such people are "closed" and you cannot reason with someone who is "closed" hence love is not achieved. Again, I've seen it too many times that the concept of love cannot be associated with ignorance and a closed system, because love doesn’t have conditions.
Let’s look at Aristotle,
“For those who are capable of reason, and [healthy] desire, act corporately as the sources of purposive motion in all animals, both human and non-human (De Anima iii 10, 433a9-16), even though, ultimately, it is desire whose objects prick practical intellect and set it in motion. For this reason, there is a faculty of desire whose activities and objects are primarily, if not autonomously or discretely, responsible for initiating end-directed motion. What we seek in action is some object of desire which is or seems to them to be good. (De Anima iii 10, 433a17-2)
I love those first words, "For those who are capable of reason . . . "
After reading Aristotle, and referring to Freud, “though what is pleasurable is not always good for us” especially if one’s mind-brain connection values and finds pleasure, let’s say in: rape, stealing, character assassination, lies and deceit, usury, and I’m sure many other unhealthy normative behaviors can be inserted here because “they” do find some pleasure in behaving contrary to reason but in accordance with their script, then it follows that without the ability to reason, “the good” cannot be fully actualized.
But, how can Steve actualize what is good and loving?
This is how I broke my cycle of vagueness and boundary violations, usury of others, invalidation and depreciation of “friends”, it was by listening to Aristotle, “Find an ethical person and imitate them”.
Freud said, “Most people would rather die than be rational, and they often do”. It was Bertrand Russell, years later, who said, “Most people would rather die than think, and most do.” Many people act out of sentiment, and I like to call them, “emotional processors” because they don’t think, and some are not even capable of being rational and reasonable rather they are following their impulses, their scripts, and their ability to think and to reason has been overwhelmed by toxic emotions, and unhealthy habits and compulsions, and that’s why I have often said,
“If you want to learn how to be reasonable and rational, find someone who is ‘doing it’ and emulate them”
Steve, and all the others who are like him, try to remember that just because a person appears to be thinking, that doesn’t make it so, they could be following a shared social or family script and they aren’t doing their own thinking. Much like puking, it might appear to be a banquet for people who value digested food but to someone who likes to grow and prepare their own food, unlike the puke-lover and drama-trauma-addicted, a healthy mind will reject and not dine on vomit and poison. So, Steve, upon what have you been dining? And, what are you offering?
This is leading me to another blog that I would like to write later because there are some people who do not know what is toxic and what is life-giving, it’s like saying, they don’t know the difference between what is right or wrong. Consequently, their behaviors reflect that inner chaos. However, that doesn’t mean that their actions are acceptable just because they don’t know what is healthy that doesn’t mean that I have to accept their abuse. I’ll give Steve an example:
Judgment of a human act consists usually of different elements: the person that commits the act, the intention they have when they do it, and the action itself. If you break a law without knowing that that law existed, you still broke it. You didn't have the intention of doing something that would break the law so you cannot be found guilty as someone who did have knowledge of the law, but you are still guilty. This can be called the 'material' part of the action, the action itself. But you also have to consider the intention and the circumstances of the person. However, the law has been broken and depending upon the severity of the Judge then a judgment will be rendered.
Another example: a person who has a mentally diminished capacity might do something like take that which doesn't belong to them. Regardless of that person's condition, that person stole. Yet he cannot be found guilty under the law due to his mental state because he can't tell the difference between what's right or wrong. However, it then becomes our responsibility and hygienic obligation to see to it that he doesn’t steal again, just as it becomes your responsibility to prevent Steve from using, abusing, and killing your psyche hence your obligation to maintain healthy boundaries and if Steve continues to violate, then it falls upon you to make the appropriate changes to either manage or stop his involvement in your life.
I have had to perform these steps on several occasions
1. recognize the violation – that assumes you have the ability to “see”
2. address the violation – with love, do not harm the violator, but lovingly inform him of his violation
3. prevent the violation – inform the violator that a rejection of the violation is not a rejection of him unless the violations continue
4. distance myself from the ongoing violation – allowing time to heal
5. leave the violator – sometimes people just have to bite, it’s part of their identity, but that doesn’t mean that you have to be his target and hunk of bleeding flesh or even believe that you are to be used and violated, unless of course you are still back on step 1, and you don’t “see”, or worse yet, you are habituated or addicted to being a victim
Dear “Steve”, because I love you, then please find an ethical and rational man, and imitate him so that being ethical and rational will eventually become your psychological habit!


















.jpg)









