From an episode of Sex & the City:
[Charlotte has just told the girls about a magazine article she read which said that a woman only gets two "Great Loves" in her lifetime]
Charlotte: So far I've only had one great love – Trey. So, girls, tell me, how many ‘Great Loves’ have you had?
Miranda: Zero.
Carrie: Really? What about Steve?
Miranda: Steve's a friend, not a core-shaker.
Samantha: Well, I'm done with great love. I'm back to great lovers.
Miranda: [to Carrie] You?
Carrie: I refuse to define love in those limited terms
Miranda: [laughing] I had to!
Charlotte: Oh, come on Carrie! Aidan and Big!
[Charlotte pauses as she realizes what she just said. Carrie looks up at her]
Carrie: One, two. And according to you, I'm done!
Charlotte: No, no, it was a stupid article. It was at the dentist!
Carrie: No, no, no, no, too late now. You said it, it's over for me. ‘Here lies Carrie. She had two loves and lots o' shoes’
I think that this brief conversation reveals much about the reality of a "Great Love" because I have seen that a "Great Love" is very difficult to define. When I look at my past experiences, and when I think about who would fall into that particular category of being one of my “Great Loves”, and, like Carrie, I am suddenly aware that I may have had my two great loves!
Clearly the magazine article that Charlotte was reading seems to have targeted women, hence the assertion that "a woman only gets two ‘Great Loves’ in her lifetime" but I disagree: gender does not have a monopoly upon what constitutes a “Great Love”. Based upon my lived experiences, and after listening to the hearts and secrets of thousands, I believe that both men and women, during a lifetime, may only experience, perhaps, two “Great Loves”, or not!
I also think that much of this concept of a “Great Love” is only as profound as the person is able to (a) experience it, and (b) maintain it. I’m not sure if the number “two” is exact, because I have met men who have had four “Great Loves” in their lives. However, those experiences were spread out over sixty years.
I’ve also met men who have attached to brutal monsters because that’s what they know best hence that really puts a qualifier on the word “Great”. I won’t bore my reader with Attachment Theory, but if you ever get a chance, please do a little reading in that area of study, and you will be amazed as to “how” some of us attach, and to “what” we attach. (Pardon me while I screaming down the road because I've made my fair share of mistakes in "attaching" to some really brutal monsters. How would I have known any better? I looked into the face of anger and avoidance and I saw "love", when in fact I saw my family of origin.)
However, for the sake of this blog I will agree that maybe if you are fortunate, you just might experience two “Great” spirits in your lifetime that have allowed you to form the basis of two “Great” and loving relationships. Personally, I am glad that I have had the opportunity to experience such men, and I still love my two "Great Loves" but still, I sense that I’m much like Carrie in this T.V. episode, and I hope that my next “Great Love” is just around the corner (how soppy does that sound?!).
You will notice that at this point I will make a seamless transition from "Great Love" to "falling in love". I believe that “falling in love” is the initial part of the definition of a "Great Love", BUT whatever you want to call the first stages, not only are infatuation and falling in love addictive, if one stays “there” then a “Great Love” cannot be possible because a healthy infatuation develops into a deeper love and it is about “us” and not about “you”! Briefly, this is only part of my interpretation of what a “Great Love” is. (Please feel free to add yours by submitting a comment.)
Do you realize that there are some people who never fall in love but they are able to use others as a sperm sponge? For complex reasons, even though that’s not falling in love or sustaining a “Great Love”, these people still seem to attach!
I’ll briefly mention a few cases. I had a patient who has never fallen in love, and I will often ask, why? Are there people incapable of psychological intimacy? I would definitely agree with that!
Are there people who just aren’t interested in sustaining and investing in another person? Again, I have to agree, these people do exist.
Are there people who have not had the opportunity to love and be loved? Yes! Also, even if they did have the opportunity to love, most of the time they did not, were not, could not, recognize, love.
In an Ideal world I would like to believe that most sane people are capable of loving, falling in love, and maintaining and sustaining the deep journey into psychological intimacy. But, if a choice in involved, I can see why one wouldn't want to fall in love, and develop toward a deeper love, for the other.
I won’t discuss the men I’ve dated for periods of time, but I will say that the two “Great Loves” that I’ve had turned out to be very painful experiences when we broke up. From the perspective of Aversion Therapy, using pain as a modifier, then not wanting to fall in love is a sane conviction IF one hasn't recovered from the pain. However, over time I have healed well, and I mostly remember the joyous times we had together, and I miss the closeness and intimacy of when the relationship was bringing us both to the fullness of fruition. Am I scared to get involved in something that would cause the same amount of pain? That depends upon the man who is courting my interests. I think the best thing that ever happened to me was being open to two "Great Loves" because these men have helped me become a better person.
I was once asked, “how do I find a Great Love?”
This much I do know, and even though the following formula is over a thousand years old, it seems to be one of the hardest to fulfill. Imagine, from the lips of a Benedictine monk, a man known as St. Aelred, attempted to answer the question by offering the following wisdom, simple and yet profound. If you want a “Great Love” then the following could be a priceless mystery because many are able to repeat the quote, but few are able to live it: “to love and be loved, to serve and be served.”
Consequently, I think it's all about finding the right balance.







