Welcome!

My photo
"it's in the conversation that we are" - Gadamer

......it's by our actions that we are known

I may be reached at the following: ecgroup at comcast.net

Tuesday, April 27, 2010

87. Great Loves: Finding The Right Balance

Great Loves: Finding The Right Balance

From an episode of Sex & the City:


[Charlotte has just told the girls about a magazine article she read which said that a woman only gets two "Great Loves" in her lifetime]


Charlotte: So far I've only had one great love – Trey. So, girls, tell me, how many ‘Great Loves’ have you had?

Miranda: Zero.

Carrie: Really? What about Steve?

Miranda: Steve's a friend, not a core-shaker.

Samantha: Well, I'm done with great love. I'm back to great lovers.

Miranda: [to Carrie] You?

Carrie: I refuse to define love in those limited terms

Miranda: [laughing] I had to!

Charlotte: Oh, come on Carrie! Aidan and Big!

[Charlotte pauses as she realizes what she just said. Carrie looks up at her]

Carrie: One, two. And according to you, I'm done!

Charlotte: No, no, it was a stupid article. It was at the dentist!

Carrie: No, no, no, no, too late now. You said it, it's over for me. ‘Here lies Carrie. She had two loves and lots o' shoes’


I think that this brief conversation reveals much about the reality of a "Great Love" because I have seen that a "Great Love" is very difficult to define. When I look at my past experiences, and when I think about who would fall into that particular category of being one of my “Great Loves”, and, like Carrie, I am suddenly aware that I may have had my two great loves!

Clearly the magazine article that Charlotte was reading seems to have targeted women, hence the assertion that "a woman only gets two ‘Great Loves’ in her lifetime" but I disagree: gender does not have a monopoly upon what constitutes a “Great Love”. Based upon my lived experiences, and after listening to the hearts and secrets of thousands, I believe that both men and women, during a lifetime, may only experience, perhaps, two “Great Loves”, or not!

I also think that much of this concept of a “Great Love” is only as profound as the person is able to (a) experience it, and (b) maintain it. I’m not sure if the number “two” is exact, because I have met men who have had four “Great Loves” in their lives. However, those experiences were spread out over sixty years.

I’ve also met men who have attached to brutal monsters because that’s what they know best hence that really puts a qualifier on the word “Great”. I won’t bore my reader with Attachment Theory, but if you ever get a chance, please do a little reading in that area of study, and you will be amazed as to “how” some of us attach, and to “what” we attach. (Pardon me while I screaming down the road because I've made my fair share of mistakes in "attaching" to some really brutal monsters. How would I have known any better? I looked into the face of anger and avoidance and I saw "love", when in fact I saw my family of origin.)

However, for the sake of this blog I will agree that maybe if you are fortunate, you just might experience two “Great” spirits in your lifetime that have allowed you to form the basis of two “Great” and loving relationships. Personally, I am glad that I have had the opportunity to experience such men, and I still love my two "Great Loves" but still, I sense that I’m much like Carrie in this T.V. episode, and I hope that my next “Great Love” is just around the corner (how soppy does that sound?!).

You will notice that at this point I will make a seamless transition from "Great Love" to "falling in love". I believe that “falling in love” is the initial part of the definition of a "Great Love", BUT whatever you want to call the first stages, not only are infatuation and falling in love addictive, if one stays “there” then a “Great Love” cannot be possible because a healthy infatuation develops into a deeper love and it is about “us” and not about “you”! Briefly, this is only part of my interpretation of what a “Great Love” is. (Please feel free to add yours by submitting a comment.)

Do you realize that there are some people who never fall in love but they are able to use others as a sperm sponge? For complex reasons, even though that’s not falling in love or sustaining a “Great Love”, these people still seem to attach!

I’ll briefly mention a few cases. I had a patient who has never fallen in love, and I will often ask, why? Are there people incapable of psychological intimacy? I would definitely agree with that!

Are there people who just aren’t interested in sustaining and investing in another person? Again, I have to agree, these people do exist.

Are there people who have not had the opportunity to love and be loved? Yes! Also, even if they did have the opportunity to love, most of the time they did not, were not, could not, recognize, love.

In an Ideal world I would like to believe that most sane people are capable of loving, falling in love, and maintaining and sustaining the deep journey into psychological intimacy. But, if a choice in involved, I can see why one wouldn't want to fall in love, and develop toward a deeper love, for the other.

I won’t discuss the men I’ve dated for periods of time, but I will say that the two “Great Loves” that I’ve had turned out to be very painful experiences when we broke up. From the perspective of Aversion Therapy, using pain as a modifier, then not wanting to fall in love is a sane conviction IF one hasn't recovered from the pain. However, over time I have healed well, and I mostly remember the joyous times we had together, and I miss the closeness and intimacy of when the relationship was bringing us both to the fullness of fruition. Am I scared to get involved in something that would cause the same amount of pain? That depends upon the man who is courting my interests. I think the best thing that ever happened to me was being open to two "Great Loves" because these men have helped me become a better person.

I was once asked, “how do I find a Great Love?”

This much I do know, and even though the following formula is over a thousand years old, it seems to be one of the hardest to fulfill. Imagine, from the lips of a Benedictine monk, a man known as St. Aelred, attempted to answer the question by offering the following wisdom, simple and yet profound. If you want a “Great Love” then the following could be a priceless mystery because many are able to repeat the quote, but few are able to live it: “to love and be loved, to serve and be served.”

Consequently, I think it's all about finding the right balance.




Saturday, April 17, 2010

86. Love Unreciprocated


I just got off the phone with a friend who has been weeping randomly for the past several weeks because he claims to love a guy with such a deep passion that he can't even sleep well. The crisis is that the "other guy" does not love him. Let's call this, "love unreciprocated or love not returned in kind."

In our conversation this evening he and I discussed the various types of love ranging from the altruistic, romance, compassion, selfless, spousal, and even the concept of preference. For example, I love ice-cream and I prefer chocolate, whereas my friend who shares my love of ice-cream prefers strawberry. I know that that's not the best example of love and preference, but I think you get the idea. Another would be that I prefer to be with a man who can celebrate emotional mutuality with me, and I'm not talking intellectual pursuits rather one who can "love and be loved, serve and be served", and I assure you, those kind of men are rare! Okay, so I have digressed from my friend's crisis, let's continue.

My friend and I are in agreement that love is very powerful, and that there are levels, and depending upon a person's awareness, that's how they will "love" and attach, and let's also remember that just because someone has attached that doesn't necessarily mean it's love!

Then there's the other dimension, for example I might love deeply my "phone friend" but that doesn't necessarily mean that I want to express that love, physically.

However, I am of the persuasion, and until I have been proven wrong, I do believe that if you truly, deeply love another guy, then you can't help but be happy to see him create the life that best meets his understanding of a healthy attachment, and love - even if that life does NOT include you.

I value happiness, and that includes the one I love, even if he does not love me. It's difficult to convey this concept of wanting what's best for the other, but I'll try. For example, I'm stating that I love him. Because I love him, I want his happiness to be complete, in as much as he is able to attach to someone to celebrate that profound dance of intimacy. And, therein lies the argument. Why would I not be happy for him if he has found his level of intimacy? And, that level may be better or less than what I can offer!

My friend just doesn't understand the concept of being self-less, or to be blunt, unselfish.

Also, let's not con-fuse, love, with sexual gratification. My friend has such a powerful physical reaction and response to the "object of his affection" that he is currently incapable of masturbating without sexually fantasizing about the "object"!

I have been trying to introduce my friend to the idea that it is ego-centric, strong-willed, whatever you want to call it when you are so focused and obsessed with the "other" that because your love isn't reciprocated that you want to destroy the companionship and friendship with the "other"!

I'm frustrated because he is determined to sabotage his friendship with the "object of his affection" just so that he "can make the 'other' feel some pain" because my friend is in pain! Fascinating, isn't it? It's like saying, "I love you, and I'm going to hurt you!" Contradictions are such remarkable motivators.

Question: How long does it take for someone to emotionally mature? Then again, this wouldn't be the first time in history when love unreciprocated has started a war!



Wednesday, April 14, 2010

85. Activist Judges: or The Big Lie

(if you want to see a larger view of the pictures then just click on them)

In the United States, many of us have known for a long time that there's a negative social value to the slur: "judicial activism".

We also know that this slur is often used whenever a court rules against what the Reichwing-neocon-wingnuts want, right now ( however, in a few years, if their desires change, they may no longer view the ruling as a negative-activism), regardless it is nice to have someone actually shout out the truth and that's what I'm going to bitch about in my blog, today.

For 30 years, at least, conservative commentators have successfully persuaded the public to believe the following deceptions:

- that conservative judges apply the law in accordance with what the Founders intended

- whereas liberal judges make up the law and enslave others or devalue life

When asked about this, according to Chief Justice John Roberts, he said that "his job is just to call 'balls and strikes', it's like being an Umpire.”

According to Justice Antonin Scalia, "conservative jurists merely carry out the 'original meaning' of the Framers."

And now, it's my turn, these statements are outright lies but they are appealing and wholly disingenuous descriptions of what judges — liberal or conservative — actually do.

If you take some time to quickly view a history of Supreme Court Law, or even review your local Superior Court Rulings, by conservative justices in the past decade, their actions (yes, I used the "a" word because that is what all judges are supposed to do: ACT, take action) however the Conservatives make it perfectly clear that they do not “apply the law” in a neutral and detached manner.


Consider, for example, the most recent Conservative Jurist decisions of the Supreme Court holding that:

- corporations have the same right of free speech as individuals

- that commercial advertising receives robust protection under the First Amendment

- that the Second Amendment prohibits the regulation of guns

- that Affirmative Action (which is based upon inclusion of minorities, and not segregation/exclusion) is unconstitutional

- that the Equal Protection Clause mandated the election of George W. Bush

- that the Boy Scouts of America have a First Amendment right to exclude Gay Scoutmasters, and that they can expel Gay members

Whatever one thinks of these decisions, it should be apparent to you by now that Conservative Judges do not disinterestedly call "balls and strikes" like Chief Justice Roberts has suggested. Rather, fueled by their own Reich-wing political and ideological convictions, they make conservative value judgments, often in an aggressively activist manner that goes well beyond anything the Framers themselves envisioned. There is nothing simple, neutral, objective or restrained about such decisions. For too long, conservatives have set the terms of the debate about judges, and they have done so in a highly misleading way. Americans should see Conservative constitutional jurisprudence for what it really is: the advancement of Corporate Rights and Christianist Ideologies. And liberals must stand up for their vision of the judiciary.

I'm angry today because Corporate Rights or "Corporate Personhood" in the Health Care Industry are financially drowning me.

For me, the clearest example of The Big Lie regarding judicial activism is the way that Republicans treated Judge Greer in the Terri Schiavo case. The Republican Judge Greer made the fatal mistake of actually calling "balls and strikes" and correctly, in accordance with Florida law, ruled against the Reich-wing and the Schiavo dead-enders, and for doing what conservatives claim they want- strict interpretations of the law. Republican Judge Greer was subjected to a smear campaign so fierce that included his being asked to leave his church. The Republican candidate for Governor in Ohio, John Kasich, told people that Judge Greer “sold out” Terri Schiavo. Greer was called a murderer, and told that he was committing judicial homicide. Yes, the Reich-wing will eat their own!

I am convinced that within the ranks of the Republican Party, and conservatives in general, that they really don’t care much about the value of Law, the Constitution, or “conservative” principles or “strict constructionism” or any of the other bullshit that rolls so effortlessly off their angry lips. HOWEVER they do care about what they want right now, and HOW they are going to get it in deference to the Law, and if they don’t get their way, suddenly you are an evil activist judge. Period.






Wednesday, April 7, 2010

84. Young Jung

I remember studying Jung, and when I was younger, how I wish I had the ability to better integrate much of his wisdom. He has written much and I won't bore anyone with reprinting his work, but there are a few insights I would like to share.

I know the following:

- I know who I fell in love with at 20 has the potential to be eerily the same type of person at 30, and even 40.

- I also know that the same type of person who I have problems with as my boss, friend or coworker can be the same type throughout my future.

If we were really honest and deeply self-aware then I'm sure Jung was right, "we can leave one relationship and find another, and continue to blame others for our negative experiences" or, I would argue, the alternative will occur in that something happens, it might be a fracture point or satiation, whatever "that" is, we suddenly develop the courage to take a closer, deeper look at our own "Shadow" and what motivates prior to playing the blame-game.

To be very brief, Carl Jung called "everything in us that is unconscious, repressed, undeveloped, and denied", and I would further add the following: and that which has been unconsciously, unknowingly or knowingly internalized as a belief and/or value. These can be dark rejected aspects of our being and lived experiences or they can be positive undeveloped potential, regardless it's all part of the Shadow that we carry within and many times we don't know, that, we don't know!

Jung believed that the Shadow is an archetype, meaning that it is typical in consciousness for everyone. In essence, we all have a Shadow and confrontation with the Shadow is essential for self-awareness. Perhaps that is why I'm often exhausted by most people who live unexamined lives because they will often hide or seek shelter for their wounded Shadow through esoteric theories, false personas or bureaucratic structures. Then again, maybe I'm just getting too old and I've seen and heard, too much!

This much I have seen, and I'm including myself, if we do not examine our Shadow then we are going to attract "it" through the mirrors of other people. That can be either a blessing or a curse.

I often remind my friends, as they share their painful life stories with me, that the heart, or whatever we wish to call the soul, isn't built in a day. It takes time, patience, and plenty of love to examine the Shadow so that we can at least befriend it rather than be enslaved by it.

I have a friend who continually blames his spouse, his boss, and several coworkers, for all of his painful, difficult experiences. It's always some other person's fault for his trouble, and I agree with him, it does take two, to Tango!

However, the Human experience is full of faults and joys, so I will often invite him to use a Freudian method of trying to re-member (as in putting the members of something back together) when he first experienced that which disturbs. Much to his surprise he keeps re-membering how he was raised, harshly, with a parent-system that was over-controlling that seemed to make Freud's concept of being "potty-trained too early in life" as a simple task. He is learning to take responsibility for what happens to him, and he is learning, gently from our shared lived experiences how to make healthier choices in dealing with others or engaging others. He is changing his attitude from blame to responsibility, not of others, but of himself, his world view, his responses and reactions.

Remember the comedian Flip Wilson? He used to say, "what you see, is what you get", there's a lot of truth in that statement. But, what if your ability to perceive reality is so dominated by the Shadow, that you can't see what's real, but you do see what is accurate in accordance with your damaged self-concept and inability to "see"! Or, would that be a disability to "see"?

For example, my friend, doesn't know it, he really is unknowing, but he's looking to replicate or re-present his whole family of origin, in others. The familiar and familial is his norm and it happens to be quite toxic, but he's unaware of that, and his understanding of love: the giving and receiving of affection, is an ongoing replication of his Shadow. He will often call it "synchronicity" when he finds another person, event or situation that "feels like home" and love. Bullshit. All that he's found is a mirror for his toxic Shadow and the significance / value of these repeating patterns of un-love, or non-love. So, we might as well bring on the whips, because pain and control, that, he understands. And, guess what, the "other" has a similar Shadow, and now they can both dance the "Danse Macabre".

My friend will often talk for hours, and I'm not joking, about a variety of people in his life who really irritate him. And, much of the time, he over-reacts and becomes deeply emotionally involved with that person, and not in a good way. Mostly, he is completely repulsed by that other person and what I find to be disturbing is that (a) he doesn't see that the "other" is part of his Shadow, and (b) he doesn't want to deal with his Shadow, but the rest of us have to take his beating because he had to engage with his Shadow, yet again, what a horrible cycle!

I have to quote Jung, "not to be able to accept various behaviors in other people or to be around them, the reaction is usually extreme distaste as these characteristics or qualities that we despise or hate in others are our own and they are usually operating outside of our awareness."

Sorry, that was a long quote...but, he further said, "They are in our unconscious and usually they will be the exact opposite of what we believe to be true about ourselves", or as I have seen, they are also re-presentations of how we were influenced and what we internalized during our developmental stages. And I believe that that is 'why' many people will "fall in love" or are drawn toward another, we are both knowingly and unconsciously projecting parts of our Shadow, positive and/or negative messages, but most of us have problems with the negative. Perhaps, if I may be so bold, it's the negative that requires the Psyche to finally say, "hey! what, am I, NOT, conscious, of?"

How often do we have to be repulsed by someone who is carrying or projecting a part of our own Shadow before we begin to deal with the inner working of our mind? What will it take to make us, 'change' toward that which is healthy? And, how do we know what health, is?

Personally, when I become critical of someone's actions, I begin to notice who has arrived in my life that irritates me. I usually discover that that is part of my own Shadow and I had better start talking with someone rational about my Shadow before I start to repeat, and re-present, the Shadow, in others.

I'm aware of how powerful the unconscious is. It has drawn, and it will draw to itself, repeatedly that which I'm carrying or projecting, and it's like a hook. A friend of mine is a 12-stepper, and he always says, "if you spot it, you got it." Perhaps that is why many closeted Homosexuals are either Homophobic or outright cruel to Homosexuals? That's just a wild thought, for the moment.....

Then again, the opposite extreme may be in our unconscious, and we will attract the parts of us that we badly need for wholeness?

Regardless of what anyone says, I really do believe that each of us, are damaged in some way, and the best way forward is through love. And, I think that the most extreme and radical act any can commit, is to love one another. Now, where have we heard THAT message before?

As for my complaining friend, I think that when he goes to extremes, what he's really doing is throwing rocks at himself because his concept of "Self" is so low and damaged that he doesn't know how to love him "Self". I can't, and I won't, condemn him but I will encourage him to learn how to love his sense of Self. I agree with Freud, "the giving and receiving of affection is a learned behavior", and many of us NEED to learn how to be affectionate with the "Self" and with others.

I'm also aware of how threatening that process can be. Why? Because it requires trust! And even deeper then that, it requires integrity and a rational mind. Therein lies a huge problem, finding someone to talk with who is rational. I've given up trying to find a rational person outside of two out of a hundred, the other ninety-eight are nucking futs, in one way or another!

To conclude I would tell my friend that there are no accidents. Both people are attracted or repelled, whatever the case may be, by an unconscious collusion. The valiant struggle is to enter into that balance between sweet and sour, or night and day, having too much of one, over-powers the other, and wholeness is balance. Until we get to that area of balance we will resent anyone who points out to us something about our character. We will be angry with them because we will feel misunderstood, and let's face it, we are being misunderstood because it took a life-time for many of us to arrive at a fucked up location before we were willing to change toward the art of balance!

If I was asked, "what are you looking for?" in my next spouse. I'm sure I would have to say, someone who will love both the light and the dark and accept my humanity so that I may accept theirs. And, isn't acceptance what we are all looking for?







Followers