Welcome!

My photo
"it's in the conversation that we are" - Gadamer

......it's by our actions that we are known

I may be reached at the following: ecgroup at comcast.net

Wednesday, December 17, 2008

9. Damn Sheeple

I've been going through the interviewing process in an attempt to find a position within my profession, and it seems that the people who are interviewing me are the same personality styles that I loathe: fucking sheeple. I find it ironic how over the decades there has been such a swing of the pendulum, and I like that metaphor that the people "we" would have not hired are the ones who are now doing the hiring!

I'm not a "paper" person, in that I don't look good on a C.V., and neither do I perform well when I know that I'm in the presence of inquisitors who have already (a) made their choice for another candidate, (b) are intimidated by me, (c) are supportive of "group-process" and lie about that, and (d) contingent on (c) dislike me because they "feel" rather than think.

The damn emotivists don't value rational thinking or reason rather they just want their assumptions and opinions validated, and they want to "feel" special. Of course, my argument is if they all want to feel "special" then no one can be "special". The sheeple either don't see or won't see their contradictions and that's okay, but what is not acceptable is reviewing me for a position on the basis of a "feeling" bias. If they can give me a good reason for not offering me a position, then I would "feel" better. But, I'm not dealing with reasonable people rather I'm being interviewed by sheep who process information through their feelings. I hope you noticed that I did not say that they "think" because they don't. They are emotivist processors!

I think this picture sums up my interview process!






Thursday, December 11, 2008

8. And The Nurse Said

I was talking with a nurse who has HIV, and she appears to be symptom-free. Of course, enquiring minds always ask her, “How did you get it?” Much to her annoyance she reminds these inquisitors that that is not the immediate question. She understands that most people ask “how” because they are scared of catching it, too. I suppose it’s a selfish reflex or reaction when most people ask, “how”.
The nurse is usually patient with inquisitors and their wild assumptions:

Did a patient give it to you?
Are you a Homosexual?
Are you sexually promiscuous?
Were you infected by bad blood-bourn medication?
She quietly tells them that once you are infected it never goes away, you can pass it on easily, sure they may be able to hide the side effects for a while, and eventually your body begins to show the signs of how the disease is slowly ravaging your body, but there is no cure. She than begins to tell them, "it's more than just an exchange of ANY body fluids, it's skin-to-skin contact, also, therein lies the potential to catch many diseases."

"How did I get it?" she would then pause and say, "How are you stopping its spread, and other diseases, too?"

She reminds her listeners that other than HIV/AIDS there are numerous diseases that can be passed just by skin-to-skin contact. Of course, her audience doesn’t want to know about “that” because they are more interested in sleuthing out the culprit who may have infected her.
Regardless of their detective-like questions, she reminds her listeners that a night of passion without a condom or forgetting to ask your friend what their HIV or health status is can be devastating and eventually lethal. No matter how small or little the mistake is it still can have the same consequence.
Within my practice I’m reminded of the young woman who was contemplating suicide because through skin-to-skin contact with her boyfriend, she was infected with:

Human Papillomavirus (HPV)
Herpes
Molluscum
Scabies
Respiratory Syncytial Virus (RSV) resulting in Pneumonia
I suspect that her thoughts of morbidity are compounded by the latter due to her extreme fatigue however it took months for her to partially recover. Unfortunately, the HPV strain she contracted led toward carcinoma. She still hasn’t tested positive for HIV but we are concerned.
The point is that I’m often emotionally overwhelmed when I hear that someone took the risk of having a physically intimate encounter with a person and neither have had any blood panel done to assess their health status. I know I sound paranoid but I’m a realist and the amount of Sexually Transmitted Diseases that I have seen on a monthly, and at times, weekly basis, are disturbing.
Regarding my friend, who is a nurse, she and I both know that the most alarming thing about HIV/AIDS today is that the majority of HIV/AIDS cases are in the youth and young adults in our community. Regardless of sexual orientation, and gender, this plague has developed a laissez-faire acceptance, and I hate it when I hear people say, “it’s no big deal” or “everyone has something”. Perhaps such an attitude is more of a characteristic of morbidity of thought and low self-worth then it is of being considerate of others. I guess there’s another issue: the lack of regard that people have for each other.
According to an article recently published by the NY Times and statistics from the American Medical Association, the diagnoses of HIV infection in gay men under the age of 30 has risen 32 percent between 2001 and 2006. Please remember, this is only based on a small test group who were willing to be tested, imagine the numbers of those who are having sex and they either don’t know or don’t care that they may have HIV or a variety of contagion.
Among black and Hispanic men, the figure was 34 percent. The number of new diagnoses among the youngest men in the study (those between ages 13 and 19) has doubled. In 2006 over 6000 gay men have died from HIV infections in the United States. (Every year the figure increases)
I’m confident that these figures are NOT TRUE because in the small city where I practice, we have greatly exceeded those statistics!

If one is going to use the NY Times as a metric standard then you will see how skewed and low those numbers are. Also, it’s not just marginalized people, the ones who have been pushed to the periphery of Heterosexist society, who are infected with a wide variety of diseases. There are numerous Heterosexuals who either go untested, or are tested but lie about their diagnosis. This is common amongst all the sexually active communities: lies, deception, ignorance and fear.

Now you might say that HIV/AIDS doesn't concern you because you sexually abstain or you always practice safe sex so you’re not to blame for this figure. But whether we blame the government for not raising more awareness in the gay teen community, or any larger sexually active grouping, or we may want to lash out at the NGO’s (Non-Government Organizations – Churches) for not handing out condoms, for practicing hate-speech and condemnation, fear and shame that further perpetuates the lack of self-regard hence more exposure to contagion, or teens not even bothering to be aware of the problem is. The fact is that you are the solution no matter who you blame for the figures it is up to you to change the future. I suppose that’s why my friend, the nurse, refuses to allow her audience to play the “blame-game” with her because we are either part of the problem or we can choose to be part of the solution, we are all involved regardless if we are sexually active. HIV/AIDS will continue to contaminate our blood-bourn medications and friends until we educate, stop the condemnation and stop ignorance.
I was thinking today about some of the reasons why the HIV/AIDS figure is so high amongst the local young gay and straight community where I live. I realize that many people who aren’t practicing safe sex are doing so with the expectation that, “a cure is just around the corner, so it’s no big deal.” What many people don’t understand, HIV/AIDS will eventually present a plethora of infections and symptoms that will potentially cripple your life, and reduce the quality of your life.
It’s important that gay teens or anybody for that matter should always wear a condom during sex (just by wearing a condom you can stop the transmission of all STD’s and HIV/AIDS) for example a condom will NOT stop skin-to-skin contact diseases.

Another good practice to get into is asking your friend/partner what their HIV and overall health status is. By spending a buck on a condom and asking a simple question you can save thousands of dollars later down the track from not buying HIV/AIDS medicine to try and slow down the disease and in general you will have a longer life.

Remember – ASLH (age, sex, location, HIV/Health status)





Thursday, November 20, 2008

7. My Kingdom Is Not Of This World



Glossary:

Christianism – When the discourse about faith and love is dominated by rigid political biblical fundamentalists, and privileged social conservatives


I have been following the arguments related to the California Initiative: Proposition 8 and I can only imagine that the Justices of the California Supreme Court are probably feeling tremendous pressure over the following:

-The Justices have fears of a recall effort, and

-Some people will not like me saying this, but it is true – The Justices also know that they have just cause to fear for their personal safety should they strike down Proposition 8.

Fixed News (FAUX-NEWS) has claimed that there are “large groups of Homosexuals”, who are “desecrating Churches and rioting in the streets”, and yet there has been no substantial proof to their claims. However one church was vandalized, and it was later discovered that the archconservative church members did it to their own church to “prove a point”. Rationally, the only point that they proved was that there is very little difference between the movement of Dr. Goebbels and conservative religious fanatics.

I have always maintained that if you can reduce your perceived “enemy” to that of being less than human then you will be able to commit any atrocity or state any lie, against them. For example, the rigid conservatives keep arguing that if “Homosexuals have all the rights of marriage, then what is next? People will be marrying goats!” By reducing Homosexuals to the concept of an “animal” then the rigid, and fearful can easily dismiss anything profound within the argument, thus confusing issues with “smelly beasts or things”.

Here is another example of bullying; many of the archconservative Christian organizations behind Proposition 8 have done much to demonize the judiciary. I suspect that the followers of “Christianism” have to do this because the judiciary has a sworn duty to protect minorities under the constitution from hate and discrimination by a rogue majority.

My belief is that it's a sad indictment against Christians who have fallen prey to “Christianism” when judges need to be fearful of the followers of Christ who have threatened physical violence. I have been following many of the major Christianism websites for years, and that is what these hate merchants are proclaiming: physical harm in the name of Jesus!

Here's what the Los Angeles Times is reporting so far:

The California Supreme Court today denied requests to stay the enforcement or implementation of Proposition 8, and at the same time agreed to decide several issues arising out of the passage of Proposition 8. The court’s order, issued in the first three cases that had been filed directly in the state’s highest court challenging the validity of Proposition 8, directed the parties to brief and argue three issues: (1) Is Proposition 8 invalid because it constitutes a revision of, rather than an amendment to, the California Constitution? (2) Does Proposition 8 violate the separation-of-powers doctrine under the California Constitution? (3) If Proposition 8 is not unconstitutional, what is its effect, if any, on the marriages of same-sex couples performed before the adoption of Proposition 8?


From what I have read and reviewed to date, the correct answers to these questions are as follows:

(1) yes, it is unconstitutional
(2) yes
(3) Proposition 8 is not retroactive and therefore does not impact legal marriages entered into prior to its enactment. A retroactive application would amount to an ex-post facto law which would be invalid under the U.S. Constitution.


Generally, the quality of the legal work of the Christianism attorneys is sub par and/or they display outright hate and disdain against Homosexuals with misinterpreted Biblical references that are not relevant to points of Constitutional Law.








Tuesday, November 18, 2008

5. But You Promised!

I’m aware that promises are not legally binding in this state, in that contract law is dependent upon an agreement that has been drawn up between two consenting adults, but seriously folks, when you make a promise, isn’t there some sense of responsibility and accountability?

We have a new colleague, just arrived in this city, and he was asking about whom within the sexually active community would not have a S.T.D. I told him that from within my patient caseload it would not be appropriate for us to discuss this question, and his reaction was, “it’s no big deal, and besides, if they aren’t still being seen by you then you can tell me.”

What part of ethics and morality courses did he sleep through?

For the sake of an argument, and overlooking the patient/practioner relationship, let’s just say that I’m not bound by any legal norms, the question that still begs to be addressed is: Aren’t we morally bound not to reveal that which we promised to hold in confidence?

My colleague believes that anything is open for discussion once the patient has left his practice. What constitutes leaving, maybe the patient is healthy and no longer requires attention hence his perceived departure? It seems that for the sake of convenience my colleague is willing to rework a promise.

My colleague is like most people, he is allergic to the following two words: responsibility and accountability.

I believe that I live within a very small minority of people who understand, and fully comprehend the concept of morality: your word is your bond, or you are dishonorable hence immoral. Other than moral philosophy, I suspect that we are observing a pattern of entitlement not only within an individual but also in social units. It’s like saying, “I want it therefore I must have it”. These people have either confused their “wants” with “needs” or it’s a matter of grandiosity. Within mental health, we would call this phenomenon: social narcissism.

If either making or keeping a promise is relative to how I feel, then it can’t be a promise by definition, and neither is the one making the promise psychologically mature enough to fulfill it. Regarding such people, I would further argue: BEWARE!










Friday, November 14, 2008

4. The Rev. Busybody: Pastor Of Deceit



I often wonder how many people, while attending their religious gatherings, are aware of that which is true, and that which is a distortion: propanda.

The other day, without permission, a minister was on campus and he had gathered a crowd of young listeners who were enjoying a lazy, sunny afternoon, while eating their lunch, outside. I'll call him, Rev. Busybody, because he's a man who is adept in creating alarm, distorting truth, and promoting fear, anger, and hatred toward anyone or anything that doesn't fit his group's Ideology.

I was sitting with a group of postgraduate students who are in Nursing Sciences, and I was listening, carefully, when Rev. Busybody said,

"People, listen to me, in the name of Jesus, we have a crisis in America. There is an unknown virus that is stalking us all. A virus that has no cure. A virus that kills. A virus that is Gay-related and it has to be crushed"

Many of the students were quiet as they listened to him wave his Bible and fist in the air as he peered into everyone's eyes.

He went on,

"Everyone knows that AIDS will kill you. People with the AIDS virus need to be registered with the government, to not only protect people who don't have it, but to protect themselves. We must put all Gays in ghettos for their own protection, special camps, we will take good care of them but they have to be removed from our cities and towns for their own protection."

Many of the students began to giggle, some stirred restlessly, while others just kept on eating and talking. He then shouted,

"If you knowingly give someone the virus, you are in any sense, a murderer. That's why we need a permit to carry a weapon. Well, AIDS is a weapon that always kills, and those who have it need to be controlled in some way, because it's being spread like wildfire and is killing innocent people every day. If you do a little research, you'll find it was not born by monkeys, or any other uneducated thing you have ever heard. It was first classified as a gay-related infectious disease, and that is what it is. I'm sorry, but facts are facts. Gays have it, and we must stop them, dead."

A student stood up and said, "My sister has HIV/AIDS from contaminated medical supplies that our government imported from China, does that mean we have to kill our government?"

Rev. Busybody ignored her and said, "Listen, everyone, the time is now to protect our children and our future. Jesus wants us to protect the innocent amongst us. The little lambs must be saved and the Lamb of God calls us to be His hands and feet, to be His Righteous Soldiers against this dreadful enemy!"

That's when several of the graduate nurses said to me, "Would you please address this fanatic because some of us are calling campus security, so before his ass is hauled off campus, please say something."


I stood up, and walked toward Rev. Busybody and his small entourage of congregants who were illegally handing out religious pamphlets, and he handed the microphone to me (he has a tiny portable speaker), and I said,

"As scientists, we know that HIV/AIDS isn’t a weapon, it is a virus that is not going to be wiped out by the voice of religion, by fear or hate, by moralizing or by registering people with the government, or by placing people in camps who have been infected by it. Imagine someone in an intimate situation saying, 'Wait, I need to see two pieces of ID and check the Internet to see if you’re registered, first.' Even that would not address the thousands who have HIV/AIDS but have not yet been diagnosed.

Many of us are genuinely concerned about the dangers of this virus and most of us do not have some hidden agenda against people who have contracted it – which certainly isn’t limited to people who are Homosexual – if you are moral, genuine and truthful in your concern over the spread of this disease, as with any other communicable disease, then you would want a wise and appropriate defense that includes education, increased prevention through the use of condoms or abstinence, and medical research."

The Rev. Busybody tried to take his microphone back by saying, "Praise Jesus, and thank you brother for the time", that's when he made a grab for the microphone but the vast majority of the students shouted, "Let the Doctor speak! SPEAK!" The Rev. Busybody stepped away and lowered his head.

I continued by saying, "For those of you who study History, you will know that the voices of fear, anger, hate, control, are so common throughout the history of all organized religions, they have destroyed or killed untold numbers of people in their zeal to save the world. There are many examples I can use, such as: The Christian Crusades, The Spanish Inquisitions, The Calvinist and Puritan Purges, these are all historical examples of how people, in the name of religion have drowned, tortured, killed, maimed, and destroyed life while trying to 'save the soul' so they burn the flesh. However, I find it disgusting and monstrous when prejudice wearing the mask of religious zeal, the mask of the Clergy or disciples of a misunderstood and misinterpreted god, will speak words of fear and hate under the guise of claiming to be performing their civic responsibility, free speech or some other, these promoters of hate propaganda are as common today as they were during the life of Jesus."

The crowd of students applauded while Rev. Busybody and his few congregants quietly slipped off campus to the roar of students yelling at him, "shame on you!"




3. Exclude Any Segment Of The Population: Atrocities Are Possible

Picture it, 1934, Nazi Germany, the government has successfully removed all consitutional and civil rights for: Jews, Homosexuals, Romani (Gypsies), Mentally Ill or Challenged, Physically Deformed, and Itelligentsia (intellectual elite), all people who did not meet the Nazi Ideal were destined for "work camps", the Ghetto, medical euthanasia, forced sterilization, medical experiments, and/or death (gas chambers).

Dr. Joseph Goebbels, the Minister For Propaganda under Adolph Hitler, taught us that, "if we can eliminate the rights of one segment of the population, then all others are at our mercy by precedent" (1933).

Certainly, it can be argued that the grim Nazi phenomena could not happen in the U.S.A., but remember, that's exactly what the German citizens said prior to 1934, "this couldn't happen in Germany!" In essence, I agree with Dr. Goebbels, he was right, if one segment of the population can be isolated and/or deprived of civil rights, then any segment that is not favored by the government or by an oppressive religious / political movement, can become a targeted group and be successfully suppressed.

Within the North West of this country, the Aryan Movement is still attempting to influence state government to prevent interracial marriages. The Aryans want to reinstate the Jim Crow Laws - Upholding or practicing discrimination against and segregation of Black people. Where, and when, will this insanity of wanting to deprive people of their Constitutional and Civil Rights, ever going to end? Again, who will be next? Dr. Goebbels was proven correct, once any group has been deprived, then the legal precedent has been established for perhaps one of the following: non-church members; common-law relationships; illegitimate children; economic segregation (the Poor are deprived of medical and social services); divorce is illegal; a return of the "color bar" to discriminate against skin color; by the way, currently, in my neighboring state, it is being "discussed" that children who "test" with lower I.Q. ratios are not to be encouraged to seek out a trade or profession (so, what do we do with "them", let them grow up, and then starve?).

Regardless of your sexual orientation, religious assumptions or political ideology, I hope that my reader will learn that once legal discrimination has been established, then it won't stop just with one targeted group.

The U.S.A., under President Bush, has learned many lessons, the one that is most toxic for our local population, and many people have yet to realize this, is: the Have-mores, will not share with the Have-less, the rich would prefer not to care and pay a fair wage to the laborer and this economic disparity has caused a lot of suffering amongst the depleted Working Middle Class. When government discriminates in favor of corporate rights at the expense of citizens then the poor become poorer, and the Middle Class disolves. Dr. Goebbels was right, in the U.S.A., corporations have more value than citizens have with their individual rights.


Here is another example: As of November, 2008, the tyranny of Heterosexism is once again being used by the Conservative Right to deny Homosexuals the right to contract their relationships in accordance with Civil Law, (not religious law) so that same-sexual couples may not have all the benefits of the state. I wonder who will be next?

Question: What is the difference between religious arrogance (the tyranny over people who do not support or believe in religion), and spreading the Gospel message of God's love? More importantly, what happened to the latter? What do we do with religious organizations that have become oppressive?

The separation of Church and State is clear: State, stay out of our Church. Church, stay out of our State. I wonder what would happen if the State decided to tax all Churches? Why not, the Churches are meddling in the policies of the State. I can just hear the people who live by double standards, and moral relativity, scream their lungs out! Then again, if the Church really loved the people of its host nation, they would want to pay taxes to help bail us out of our economic depression. I suppose I'm an idealist, imagine, any Church, wanting to financially return back to the nation a portion of that which was given to them!


Harvey Fierstein asks the question: Where Is Our Anger?












Thursday, November 13, 2008

2. Being Right: Ethically, Is It Just A Matter Of Opinion?

What does one say to a person who is of the opinion, and belief that they are nearly always right? Here is an example:

Peter said, “I believe that only couples who have been married by the Church should receive benefits from the state.”

Rick asked, “Upon what, do you base this position?”

Peter: “It is my belief that we are a Christian nation so only Christians should benefit state rights.”

Rick: “Well, that certainly is your opinion.”

Peter: “No, it is more than my opinion, it’s based on the Bible.”

Rick: “We call that, religious assumptions hence opinions, and many of us do not share your assumptions and opinions.”

Peter: “That’s your opinion and ethics are just a matter of opinions, and our opinions disagree.”


Question: In Ethics, and the struggle to be right, is it just a matter of opinion?


Ethics includes the consideration of what people should do, and why. It's not "just" a matter of opinion. For example, someone is not the Queen of England, just because she holds to that opinion, and believes she is. We put most people who act out of such beliefs and opinions into mental hospitals. They need some serious help.

Of course, the Queen of England also happens to be of the opinion, and belief that she is the Queen of England, but it's not her opinion that makes this true. She really is the Queen of England.

Consequently, we are challenged with the perception that there must be some other criterion by which we are able to determine whose opinion is right, and whose is wrong.

Let's make a distinction here. There are "matters of taste", and "matters of truth" (thank you, Mortimer Adler), and one's own opinion, is what determines matters of taste and preference.

If I am of the opinion that broccoli tastes good, and you are not, we can both be right. It can taste good to one of us, and not to the other.

However, in matters of perceiving the truth, the criterion is not our own taste buds.

When we speak of the actions of human beings that affect other human beings, the criterion is not personal tastes rather it's reason. Therein lies the crisis when we are attempting to dialogue with another person: reason.

For example, if we disagree on what should be done we give our reasons, and if we don't, we're asked for them. However, some people have confused reason with excuses, feelings, and opinions.

This does not mean, however, that the only basis for the morality of a human action can be reason. In response to the question, "Why did you do that?" A good reason might be, "Because I care about you." Feelings are sometimes good reasons for doing good things.

But if you just slapped me, and then claim you did so because you care about me ..... well, perhaps you should consider “visiting” some of the Queen Elizabeths from the first paragraph.

Remember, matters of opinion are of two types, it can be good for you, but not for me whereas ethics are not.

So, the next time someone comments that ethics are just “a matter of opinion”, remember that matters of opinion are of two types, and ethics are not, as this statement usually implies, matters of taste.

You might consider a response like this one:

"Yes, ethics are matters of opinion. But, the important question is whether that opinion is right? or wrong?"



1. I Believe, Therefore It Is True, Or Not!


Copernicus hypothesized that the Sun was the center of the universe, and that the Earth is in its rotation, Religion had dominated Science, and many assumed that the Earth was the center of the universe because Man was the Ultimate Creation. The Church at that time was even willing to kill any person who disagreed with the Flat-Earth concept or the idea that the Earth, and Man, are not the center of the System!

We are still seeing this today in the New Thought movements where people are claiming special, unique, individualized messages from “God”, a “Kabal” and / or “Something” greater than mere unenlightened mortals.

Kant argued, “We must therefore make trial, whether we may not have more success … if we suppose that objects must conform to our knowledge.”


This is still a radical proposal because he was asking us to use critical thinking skills, to test, to ask questions, and to rationally interpret our environment not through our feelings, intuition, or because a perceived authority, said so!

Kant was asking us to THINK carefully as to the potential of what “is”. Notice that the word "potential" is used, and not "possibilities".

Think about it for a moment, if “anything is possible”, then nothing is possible.

Therefore, we must live within potential. Kant believed that the mind will constitute the way we perceive the world, and the way in which the world is experienced. Of course, my concerns are:

How many of us will actually THINK rather than FEEL about an issue or thing?

What if the mind is predisposed to an underlying pathologic style, or an obvious psychopathology?

How is the person to know if they perceive through a learned script regardless if it is an individual, or shared familial and socially acceptable perception?

Are we aware of that which distorts reality from the truth?


I respect the benefits, and healthy effects, that psychopharmacology and psychoanalysis can provide. Especially for people who are not perceiving reality as it is rather they are living in a deficient and nescient world view. Perhaps the person is delusional, and/or influenced by a pathology, or their ability to "see" is bound by a layered-learned script that is familiar and/or familial. If so, then that is what the mind is going to perceive.

Here is an example:


I remember asking a few graduate students the following question. I took them out during a warm August night, and much to our joy there was a “Harvest Moon”, it was full, glowing and beautiful. The air was pungent with the harvest air because we live in a rich and diverse agricultural area. I asked each the following, “While looking up at the sky, what do you see?”

The first man said, “I see the face of my beloved.”


The second man said, “I see the most delicious pizza pie.”

The third man said, “I see Homeland Security spying on us, a camera in the sky.”

The fourth man said, “I see the sign of god's love by night."


The fifth man said, "I see the radiance of our moon"

The first man was deeply in love, and no matter what he encountered, everything reminded him of his love. His mind was filled with the emotions of infatuation.

The second man had not eaten much that day, and he was ruled by his natural cravings for food. He saw food-products in diverse locations, even a brick looked like a loaf of bread.

The third man was obsessed with justice, law, police actions, and monitoring. He was constantly looking for spies and “the enemy”. In his vigilance he saw conspiracies nearly everywhere, and he perceived his environment to be hostile.

The fourth man perceived reality through a religious group's consciousness. Things were not as they are rather they were to be interpreted within the language of his religious layering, the familiar and perhaps the familial.


The fifth man was not distracted by romantic feelings, hunger, authority issues, or a group's conscious control, he truly saw the moon!

Kant taught that the mind, when it is healthy, constitutes the way the world appears and the way in which the world is thought about. Kant never argued that the mind will create an object but only the interior conditions under which objects are perceived, comprehended and understood.

The question is: What are we doing, what is our mind doing, when we encounter stimuli, an object or an interpersonal encounter? Are we perceiving clearly or are we comprehending through a lens, darkly?

I remember talking with a student and we were looking at a magnificent oak tree, and he said, “Woden would be proud of such a tree, it is a fine altar to his glory.” I knew that he was interested in his family’s Scandinavian history but I was unaware that he had integrated the mythology of Woden into his belief and value system.


Consequently, he didn’t see an oak tree for being an oak rather it was the instrument of Woden’s Will. The tree had become a conduit for the Norse gods’ access to this world. Certainly, that is his opinion, and belief, but just because someone has an opinion and belief, that doesn’t make it true.

I can argue that I am the King of Spain, but my opinion and aggressively held belief doesn't support my argument because there really is a King of Spain, and he is living proof of his existence. That is why I do my best to urge patients and students to carefully examine and critique the biases and bases of their belief systems. If we believe within our bias that something is true, then usually our actions will follow, and not all of our beliefs, are true.





Followers