
Here are a few of my musings now that I am in the midst of moving and I can’t focus on various academic pursuits, so I’ll play with a few conceptual toys!
I hope my reader will enjoy what I find amusing!
Much of my work with people is trying to discern how a common language has been encoded and layered. For example, I might be talking with a patient and we are both using the same language of English but we are not communicating because of various cultural, educational, genetic and experiential reasons. Because of this, I often think of Immanuel Kant’s Golden Rule in Philosophy, and how a variety of people, social units, and individuals will conceptualize and apply morality, ethics and especially in the way they will process information. Again, notice I did not necessarily say, “think” through issues rather they manage the information through a wide variety of categorizations and perspectives (filters, opinions, assumptions), which may not lead to a rational, cogent and coherent perception or answer.
Kant’s overarching principle, the criterion for all other ethical maxims, is what he calls the “Supreme Categorical Imperative.” When I first heard this, I immediately thought of my mother because she was “Supreme”, just ask dad, and she would often say “treat others like you would like to be treated”, it was the “Golden Rule” of our home life.
Here is the North American version of the Golden Rule: “Do unto others as you would have others do unto you.”
Kant worded his Supreme Categorical Imperative by saying: “Act only according to that maxim whereby you can at the same time will that it should become a universal law.”
Behold the two: The Supreme Categorical Imperative, and The Golden Rule.
Now, I have a problem with Kant. Don’t get me wrong, I do love the guy and much of his work is stunning, however, identical with Jesus, I have to say, “oh Lord, save me from his followers!” That’s right, I do believe that most Kantians, like most Christians, “they don’t get it”.

Kant has certainly been passed around, a lot! But, have we truly understood much of what he had to say?
It seems that many of the Neo-Kantians have introduced his work with a very cold and forthright, unbending interpretation. For example, the very term “Supreme Categorical Imperative” sounds very Germanic in culture, and most definitely Prussian! Let’s not forget that Kant wrote much of his work while he was living under the scrutiny of a forty-six year rule from one of the greatest military geniuses of his time, and that leader was one of the most remarkable, brilliant, well-educated, and benevolent dictators of his day: King Frederick II, or he was also known as “Frederick The Great of Prussia”. He was feared by every monarchy in Europe because they knew that “Frederick” could have a standing army in the field within twenty-four hours, and that army was one of the most disciplined and aggressive for that era. It was even said that even the mighty Czars of Russia dared not to entice Frederick the Great because they knew that he was always looking for an invitation to claim more land and to expand his empire. Consequently, every monarch made sure they were at peace with his rule. Therefore much of Kant’s language is disguised, and I’ll illustrate that, later.

Meanwhile, before Frederick became "The Great", we won’t discuss in detail how young Prince Frederick’s father had the prince’s male lover executed while Frederick was a very young man, it was a “lesson” in “duty” to the Crown, at least, that’s how his father, the King, saw it.
Apparently, the young handsome Prince Frederick, before he was "The Great", was trying to escape his father’s cruel authoritarian rule with the help of Hans Herman von Katte, and it was known widely at the Imperial Prussian Court that the young Prince and Hans, were lovers, however his father had other plans for his son, and those plans did not include non-breeding Homosexuality or fleeing from “duty”!

I digress, but this much is certain, if you are going to read Kant, then be prepared for a cultural and social journey into a Prussian Empire with an Absolute monarchy who watched everyone and everything, hence when Kant wrote, his style was very Prussian, and not cold “Germanic”, there is a distinction, ask a Prussian, and they’ll tear your ears off for not knowing!
Why is it that many Neo-Kantians are so rigid in their interpretation of Kant? I suspect it’s because they made the assumption that Kant was a cultural idiot or he willingly chose to be subservient to an absolute monarch. I’ll give you an example of what it's like to be subservient or in "relativity" with authoritarianism:
Within the last century, a majority of people, and let’s use Nazi Germany in 1936 as our example, voted to amend their Constitutional Law by including Jews, Homosexuals, the Roma (Gypsies), Mentally Retarded, and any who defy the state, as being not worthy or allowed to benefit from the state: they couldn’t marry, hold Office, engage in business, or own property. Also, within the year of that law, many of these people were hunted down and eventually sent to their death.

Even though Kant lived under a dictatorship, Kant would remind his reader: “Seek not the favor of the multitude; it is seldom got by honest and lawful means. But seek the testimony of few; and number not voices, but weigh them.” I would argue that just because a tyranny of the majority spoke, that doesn’t mean they are right, moral, ethical or rational, and Kant knew this! Follow my line of reasoning for a moment, and I’ll show you why I fear many Neo-Kantians and their inability to reason, or “weigh”, events rather they are good at quoting him.

Kant: “He who is cruel to animals becomes hard also in his dealings with men. We can judge the heart of a man by his treatment of animals.” I know of several Neo-Kantians who hunt, cruelly kill, torture, and mistreat animals, and yet they are like many Christians, they can quote chapter and verse but do they comprehend what they are saying, obviously, Kant would say, “no!”

Kant: “Experience without theory is blind, but theory without experience is mere intellectual play.” When the Nazis were moving through Europe, many Kantians who were hiding Jews and Homosexuals would not lie to the Gestapo when they were asked, “is there a Homosexual or Jew in your house?” because of what Kant said, “By a lie, a man... annihilates his dignity as a man.” Unknowingly, they don’t understand that Kant understood that if you are in an absolute regime, totalitarian, then your experiences and reason would tell you to be honorable, and save the life of the person you are hiding even though it does a disservice to the listener by lying, the issue is one of life therefore you honor life by saving a life!
Kant: “It is not necessary that whilst I live I live happily; but it is necessary that so long as I live I should live honorably.”
Kant: “May you live your life as if the maxim of your actions were to become universal law.” If it is permissible to hunt down and kill anyone who is “different” then it follows that that maxim will become a universal law if one is irrational, and we nearly ended up in those dark bowels under President Shrub.
Kant: “Always recognize that human individuals are ends, and do not use them as means to your end.” Herein lies the crux of the matter, one does not treat another person as a means to an end, regardless of how bloody that end is, or how glorious. This in itself would have motivated a true Kantian to defy any means that would end in killing another, using another person for their gratification or sport, or causing harm to another person.




Kant: “All our knowledge begins with the senses, proceeds then to the understanding, and ends with reason. There is nothing higher than reason.” And, that’s why we have to choose the lesser of two shitty choices because we are not living in a perfect world, but we can reason toward a healthier choice, right?
Reason. Kantians, people, are you listening? Reason! I have to sigh when I use that word because people seldom reason. I can’t count the multitudes of people who are following a wide variety of scripts and they are not being reasonable and neither do they reason but they are analytical in following their inner scripts / voices / assumptions / beliefs / opinions / sick values etc.
However, let’s revisit the categorical imperative and the golden rule, and let’s see how they seem to share a lot of philosophical territory:
If you notice, and I hope you are able to make this distinction, but neither of these “rules”, is a rule about specific action, like “Honor thy father and mother” or “Eat your spinach!”
Instead, both provide an abstract principle for determining which specific actions are right and which are wrong, or do they?
In both, this abstract principle invokes the idea that all people (how Prussian to make such an assumption) are as valuable as you and me, and so all should be treated morally the same as you and me, particularly me. That’s assuming again that we are both speaking and comprehending the same language because what if you are talking with someone who has a character disorder? Kant didn’t consider the limits of the Human brain, and the lack of ecology of the mind. Especially when it has to be “all about me, me, me, me, me!”
I believe that there is a fundamental difference between the categorical imperative and the golden rule, and this one-liner is explicit:
A sadist is a masochist, who follows the golden rule.


From the many patients I have seen over much time, I know of many who would interpret the categorical imperative and the golden rule in accordance with either their psychological style or disorder. Relativity. They have to, until they have received therapy, that’s what people with character disorders, do, they follow their script. Relativist, that’s what they do, they follow their script. Then again, one need not have a full-blown disorder, they could just be full of self-hate or they could be living an unexamined life!
The masochist, in inflicting pain on others, is only doing what the golden rule requires: “doing what he would like done unto him”, preferably with a whip. That reminds me, I remember a “friend” from years ago who couldn’t achieve orgasm unless you defecated on him, and for him, it was absolute, but does that make it a universal? He would argue that that is how he would want it to be hence the conflict of mind and the golden rule!
But Kant would say that there’s no way the masochist could honestly claim that the moral imperative, “inflict pain on others,” could be a universal law for a livable world. Even a masochist would find that unreasonable. Oh! Really, Dr. Kant?!
Personally, I doubt that Kant was diagnostically equipped to recognize how a person with a character disorder would interpret and live out of a “universal law”, and if Kant doesn’t believe me, I have a few “bath houses”, “leather bars” and online sites, and other denigrating venues to show him of how, as Martin Luther said, “much like a dog returning to his puke, he regards it like a banquet” as he continuously returns to the feast without hesitation.

Similar considerations led English playwright George Bernard Shaw to wryly rewrite the golden rule: “do not do unto others as you would have others do unto you; they may have different taste.” Now, we are into “preferences”, and again, it seems that even Shaw somehow perceived that depending upon an individual’s ecology of the mind, or a social unit’s sociology of the mind, then behaviors will follow.
I went hunting online, and here are a few variations on the golden rule as found not only in Kant but in a few religious traditions from around the world, in other words, Kant may have been re-presenting a universal cultural “hope”. As I think about that, I’m aware that that’s how I “see it”, we are looking at a universal hope of what is reasonable.
Hinduism (Thirteenth Century Before the Christian Era – B.C.E.)
Do not to others what ye do not wish done to yourself … This is the whole Dharma. Heed it well. - The Mahabharata
Judaism (Thirteenth Century B.C.E.)
What is hateful to you, do not do to your neighbor; that is the entire Torah; the rest is commentary; go learn it. - The Babylonian Talmud
Zoraostrianism (Twelfth Century B.C.E.)
Human nature is good only when it does not do unto another whatever is not good for its own self. - The Dadistan-i-Dinik
Buddhism (Sixth Century B.C.E.)
Hurt not others in ways that you yourself would find hurtful. - The Tibetan Dhammapada
Confucianism (Sixth Century B.C.E.)
Do not do to others what you do not want done to yourself. - Confucius, The Analects
Islam (Seventh Century Anno Domini, year of the Christian Era - A.D.)
No one of you is a believer until you desire for another that which you desire for yourself.
- The Sunnah, from the Hadith
Baha’I (Nineteenth Century A.D.)
Ascribe not to any soul that which thou wouldst not have ascribed to thee, and say not that which thou does not. This is my command unto thee, do thou observe it. -
Bahua u llah, The hidden Words
Sopranoism (Twenty-First Century A.D.)
Whack the next guy with the same respect you would like to be whacked with, you know, capiche?
My hope: For reason to prevail, may Life lead many towards in-depth psychoanalytical therapy!





















