Welcome!

My photo
"it's in the conversation that we are" - Gadamer

......it's by our actions that we are known

I may be reached at the following: ecgroup at comcast.net

Monday, March 23, 2009

23. Kant Can't: The Golden Rule, Or Not!



Here are a few of my musings now that I am in the midst of moving and I can’t focus on various academic pursuits, so I’ll play with a few conceptual toys!

I hope my reader will enjoy what I find amusing!

Much of my work with people is trying to discern how a common language has been encoded and layered. For example, I might be talking with a patient and we are both using the same language of English but we are not communicating because of various cultural, educational, genetic and experiential reasons. Because of this, I often think of Immanuel Kant’s Golden Rule in Philosophy, and how a variety of people, social units, and individuals will conceptualize and apply morality, ethics and especially in the way they will process information. Again, notice I did not necessarily say, “think” through issues rather they manage the information through a wide variety of categorizations and perspectives (filters, opinions, assumptions), which may not lead to a rational, cogent and coherent perception or answer.

Kant’s overarching principle, the criterion for all other ethical maxims, is what he calls the “Supreme Categorical Imperative.” When I first heard this, I immediately thought of my mother because she was “Supreme”, just ask dad, and she would often say “treat others like you would like to be treated”, it was the “Golden Rule” of our home life.

Here is the North American version of the Golden Rule: “Do unto others as you would have others do unto you.”

Kant worded his Supreme Categorical Imperative by saying: “Act only according to that maxim whereby you can at the same time will that it should become a universal law.”

Behold the two: The Supreme Categorical Imperative, and The Golden Rule.

Now, I have a problem with Kant. Don’t get me wrong, I do love the guy and much of his work is stunning, however, identical with Jesus, I have to say, “oh Lord, save me from his followers!” That’s right, I do believe that most Kantians, like most Christians, “they don’t get it”.



Kant has certainly been passed around, a lot! But, have we truly understood much of what he had to say?

It seems that many of the Neo-Kantians have introduced his work with a very cold and forthright, unbending interpretation. For example, the very term “Supreme Categorical Imperative” sounds very Germanic in culture, and most definitely Prussian! Let’s not forget that Kant wrote much of his work while he was living under the scrutiny of a forty-six year rule from one of the greatest military geniuses of his time, and that leader was one of the most remarkable, brilliant, well-educated, and benevolent dictators of his day: King Frederick II, or he was also known as “Frederick The Great of Prussia”. He was feared by every monarchy in Europe because they knew that “Frederick” could have a standing army in the field within twenty-four hours, and that army was one of the most disciplined and aggressive for that era. It was even said that even the mighty Czars of Russia dared not to entice Frederick the Great because they knew that he was always looking for an invitation to claim more land and to expand his empire. Consequently, every monarch made sure they were at peace with his rule. Therefore much of Kant’s language is disguised, and I’ll illustrate that, later.



Meanwhile, before Frederick became "The Great", we won’t discuss in detail how young Prince Frederick’s father had the prince’s male lover executed while Frederick was a very young man, it was a “lesson” in “duty” to the Crown, at least, that’s how his father, the King, saw it.

Apparently, the young handsome Prince Frederick, before he was "The Great", was trying to escape his father’s cruel authoritarian rule with the help of Hans Herman von Katte, and it was known widely at the Imperial Prussian Court that the young Prince and Hans, were lovers, however his father had other plans for his son, and those plans did not include non-breeding Homosexuality or fleeing from “duty”!



I digress, but this much is certain, if you are going to read Kant, then be prepared for a cultural and social journey into a Prussian Empire with an Absolute monarchy who watched everyone and everything, hence when Kant wrote, his style was very Prussian, and not cold “Germanic”, there is a distinction, ask a Prussian, and they’ll tear your ears off for not knowing!

Why is it that many Neo-Kantians are so rigid in their interpretation of Kant? I suspect it’s because they made the assumption that Kant was a cultural idiot or he willingly chose to be subservient to an absolute monarch. I’ll give you an example of what it's like to be subservient or in "relativity" with authoritarianism:

Within the last century, a majority of people, and let’s use Nazi Germany in 1936 as our example, voted to amend their Constitutional Law by including Jews, Homosexuals, the Roma (Gypsies), Mentally Retarded, and any who defy the state, as being not worthy or allowed to benefit from the state: they couldn’t marry, hold Office, engage in business, or own property. Also, within the year of that law, many of these people were hunted down and eventually sent to their death.



Even though Kant lived under a dictatorship, Kant would remind his reader: “Seek not the favor of the multitude; it is seldom got by honest and lawful means. But seek the testimony of few; and number not voices, but weigh them.” I would argue that just because a tyranny of the majority spoke, that doesn’t mean they are right, moral, ethical or rational, and Kant knew this! Follow my line of reasoning for a moment, and I’ll show you why I fear many Neo-Kantians and their inability to reason, or “weigh”, events rather they are good at quoting him.



Kant: “He who is cruel to animals becomes hard also in his dealings with men. We can judge the heart of a man by his treatment of animals.” I know of several Neo-Kantians who hunt, cruelly kill, torture, and mistreat animals, and yet they are like many Christians, they can quote chapter and verse but do they comprehend what they are saying, obviously, Kant would say, “no!”



Kant: “Experience without theory is blind, but theory without experience is mere intellectual play.” When the Nazis were moving through Europe, many Kantians who were hiding Jews and Homosexuals would not lie to the Gestapo when they were asked, “is there a Homosexual or Jew in your house?” because of what Kant said, “By a lie, a man... annihilates his dignity as a man.” Unknowingly, they don’t understand that Kant understood that if you are in an absolute regime, totalitarian, then your experiences and reason would tell you to be honorable, and save the life of the person you are hiding even though it does a disservice to the listener by lying, the issue is one of life therefore you honor life by saving a life!

Kant: “It is not necessary that whilst I live I live happily; but it is necessary that so long as I live I should live honorably.”

Kant: “May you live your life as if the maxim of your actions were to become universal law.” If it is permissible to hunt down and kill anyone who is “different” then it follows that that maxim will become a universal law if one is irrational, and we nearly ended up in those dark bowels under President Shrub.

Kant: “Always recognize that human individuals are ends, and do not use them as means to your end.” Herein lies the crux of the matter, one does not treat another person as a means to an end, regardless of how bloody that end is, or how glorious. This in itself would have motivated a true Kantian to defy any means that would end in killing another, using another person for their gratification or sport, or causing harm to another person.






Kant: “All our knowledge begins with the senses, proceeds then to the understanding, and ends with reason. There is nothing higher than reason.” And, that’s why we have to choose the lesser of two shitty choices because we are not living in a perfect world, but we can reason toward a healthier choice, right?

Reason. Kantians, people, are you listening? Reason! I have to sigh when I use that word because people seldom reason. I can’t count the multitudes of people who are following a wide variety of scripts and they are not being reasonable and neither do they reason but they are analytical in following their inner scripts / voices / assumptions / beliefs / opinions / sick values etc.

However, let’s revisit the categorical imperative and the golden rule, and let’s see how they seem to share a lot of philosophical territory:

If you notice, and I hope you are able to make this distinction, but neither of these “rules”, is a rule about specific action, like “Honor thy father and mother” or “Eat your spinach!”

Instead, both provide an abstract principle for determining which specific actions are right and which are wrong, or do they?

In both, this abstract principle invokes the idea that all people (how Prussian to make such an assumption) are as valuable as you and me, and so all should be treated morally the same as you and me, particularly me. That’s assuming again that we are both speaking and comprehending the same language because what if you are talking with someone who has a character disorder? Kant didn’t consider the limits of the Human brain, and the lack of ecology of the mind. Especially when it has to be “all about me, me, me, me, me!”

I believe that there is a fundamental difference between the categorical imperative and the golden rule, and this one-liner is explicit:

A sadist is a masochist, who follows the golden rule.




From the many patients I have seen over much time, I know of many who would interpret the categorical imperative and the golden rule in accordance with either their psychological style or disorder. Relativity. They have to, until they have received therapy, that’s what people with character disorders, do, they follow their script. Relativist, that’s what they do, they follow their script. Then again, one need not have a full-blown disorder, they could just be full of self-hate or they could be living an unexamined life!

The masochist, in inflicting pain on others, is only doing what the golden rule requires: “doing what he would like done unto him”, preferably with a whip. That reminds me, I remember a “friend” from years ago who couldn’t achieve orgasm unless you defecated on him, and for him, it was absolute, but does that make it a universal? He would argue that that is how he would want it to be hence the conflict of mind and the golden rule!

But Kant would say that there’s no way the masochist could honestly claim that the moral imperative, “inflict pain on others,” could be a universal law for a livable world. Even a masochist would find that unreasonable. Oh! Really, Dr. Kant?!

Personally, I doubt that Kant was diagnostically equipped to recognize how a person with a character disorder would interpret and live out of a “universal law”, and if Kant doesn’t believe me, I have a few “bath houses”, “leather bars” and online sites, and other denigrating venues to show him of how, as Martin Luther said, “much like a dog returning to his puke, he regards it like a banquet” as he continuously returns to the feast without hesitation.



Similar considerations led English playwright George Bernard Shaw to wryly rewrite the golden rule: “do not do unto others as you would have others do unto you; they may have different taste.” Now, we are into “preferences”, and again, it seems that even Shaw somehow perceived that depending upon an individual’s ecology of the mind, or a social unit’s sociology of the mind, then behaviors will follow.


I went hunting online, and here are a few variations on the golden rule as found not only in Kant but in a few religious traditions from around the world, in other words, Kant may have been re-presenting a universal cultural “hope”. As I think about that, I’m aware that that’s how I “see it”, we are looking at a universal hope of what is reasonable.



Hinduism (Thirteenth Century Before the Christian Era – B.C.E.)

Do not to others what ye do not wish done to yourself … This is the whole Dharma. Heed it well. - The Mahabharata


Judaism (Thirteenth Century B.C.E.)

What is hateful to you, do not do to your neighbor; that is the entire Torah; the rest is commentary; go learn it. - The Babylonian Talmud


Zoraostrianism (Twelfth Century B.C.E.)

Human nature is good only when it does not do unto another whatever is not good for its own self. - The Dadistan-i-Dinik


Buddhism (Sixth Century B.C.E.)

Hurt not others in ways that you yourself would find hurtful. - The Tibetan Dhammapada


Confucianism (Sixth Century B.C.E.)

Do not do to others what you do not want done to yourself. - Confucius, The Analects


Islam (Seventh Century Anno Domini, year of the Christian Era - A.D.)

No one of you is a believer until you desire for another that which you desire for yourself.
- The Sunnah, from the Hadith


Baha’I (Nineteenth Century A.D.)

Ascribe not to any soul that which thou wouldst not have ascribed to thee, and say not that which thou does not. This is my command unto thee, do thou observe it. -
Bahua u llah, The hidden Words


Sopranoism (Twenty-First Century A.D.)

Whack the next guy with the same respect you would like to be whacked with, you know, capiche?






My hope: For reason to prevail, may Life lead many towards in-depth psychoanalytical therapy!






22. A Conversation Before I Die: Excerpts From A Verbatim

WITH HIS PERMISSION

This blog is dedicated to a man who is in his mid twenties, before he dies; these are a few excerpts, a verbatim of his thoughts, feelings and his lived experiences from our lengthy conversation:




- I only had a few sexual partners in my life. Met them on various online sites, but that doesn’t really matter, you can meet any guy, even while selecting apples at Yokes.

- I never did anything sexually risky.

- The feel of rubbing my naked body against his was awesome. Didn’t do much of anything else, just some oral, plenty of kissing, and then a hand-job.

- About three months ago, a rash, looked like a group of pimples, a few puss-heads, prickly, hot, annoying. The Dermatologist treated it with several creams, lotions, it started to spread.

- Two weeks after that rash started, and while the rash was still screaming on my thigh, my sinuses began to block, stuffy nose, runny, congested, inflamed, and irritated. Antibiotics and drops did very little for my sinuses, and then the unthinkable happened.

- A month after the rash, and as it was slowly growing, it was a Friday night, wouldn’t you know it would happen on a weekend night. I spiked a rapidly climbing fever. My sister brought me into the E.R. and I was spiking at 104 degrees with sweats and chills, and I really got the attention of the physicians and nurses, really fast. My cough was loose with plenty of odd colored phlegm. After a night from Hell in the E.R. they moved me upstairs. I think it’s called: isolation.

- I was on that floor for ten long miserable days. The strangest kind of pneumonia, rarely seen. It was parasite related, they said.

- Remember when I was studying to be a nurse? I do remember my anatomy and physiology classes. Parasite related pneumonia. What the fuck! I don’t remember studying that, but I do understand how the body is all interconnected, so how can it only be contained in the lung?

- Before I was released from the hospital the other day, they told me I’m HIV Poz. I nearly fainted from shock and fear. They said I can leave for the weekend but on Monday morning they want to irradiate parts of my lung. Think of it, they are going to fry parts of my lung. You know what that means, don’t you, in the long run, you know what that means. Kill the parasites, I guess, but what about the other sites, the other locations. The brain, the lymph, the other sites?

- You warned me last summer about skin-to-skin contact. I’m so sad, angry, scared, and I want vengeance against the guy who gave me this. You told me to get to know a man before I get naked with him. Hell, even saliva isn’t safe any more, you warned me, and I guess I was looking for love and acceptance in all the wrong ways and with all the wrong guys. But you know what really makes me angry? I have only had sex with five men in my entire life. Only five guys, and not all at the same time, either, please know that. And you know what? These same five guys I had sex with are still out there, having sex with other men, some are traveling. So, if I have this from one of them, how many others have been infected? How many others are not symptomatic but are carriers? Let’s face it, one of them exposed me to this and he’s still out there. Maybe he doesn’t know he has Herpes and HIV. What else would he be carrying? or maybe, they are all carrying something? Maybe that one guy does know it, this is driving me nuts.

- You told me that the giving and receiving of affection is learned for most people, you said that Freud said that, and you know what? You are both right, and now I’m paying the price for wanting affection from the wrong type of guys, I should correct myself, from the wrong guy because intimacy can only happen between two souls who are mature and totally present to each other, and over a period of time of getting to know each other, first. You were right when you said that last summer to me.

- Have you ever been with a man who can complete your sentences? He knows your thoughts? He feels your feelings? He is inside your head. I am looking for that. I thought I had it once but he left for a bigger cock. You said that that kind of intimacy is possible, that kind of spiritual or deep connection is possible between two people but it only happens rarely, and I was looking for that holistic relationship and what I don’t understand is why are such men so rare?

- Why didn’t you date me last summer?

- I’m not angry with you, but I often think, what if you and I were lovers, then I wouldn’t be here, in this condition. I guess that’s not fair to you, or me, because we all have our preferences, our levels of awareness, and our underdevelopment. You know what? I don’t think I was ready for you in the summer. And now, now that I’m understanding what you always said, how can we be lovers if we can’t be the best of friends, now I’m getting it, but it’s too late for me, isn’t it?

- Interferon B will be used after the irradiation, or perhaps starting on Monday morning, I’ll be hit with both the chemo and irradiation, just to kill the parasites.

- I see you staring at me with those deep green eyes, and I know you are reading my soul. But what hurts the most, is that you can see that I lost my gym body from last summer. I remember how disgusted you were with me for having an eight-pack last summer. I know that you were joking and it made me feel great to pose like a crazy gym nut. Today, I’m ashamed that you can see that I have lost eighty pounds since July. I’m scared. To be over six feet tall and weighing in at a generous 120 pounds, it’s scary. I see that you are still reading my soul, and I have nothing to hide from you, why would I hide from a man like you? Only a nut would hide from you.

- I can say with pride and honor that I never did drugs. Well, that’s not true, I only took the drugs my physicians prescribed. I'm not lying. I have nothing to gain by lying. I'm going to die, so why lie to a man who loves without question?

- You are quiet again.

- Your eyes are soft as they look into what’s left of my blue eyes. Do you know what it’s like to stare into a mirror and not recognize yourself?

- I can’t eat.

- Sometimes, I can hold down what I drink.

- Remember the lemon drop I made for you in July? That was your favorite. I guess I wasn’t your favorite, but that’s okay. I wasn’t ready, but on some level, I saw you. I mean, I really saw you, but the brilliance of your heart scared the Hell out of me but it also made me to want more of you, and if I can't have you, then where does one find another sun?

- I’m going to die.

- I was looking for love but I didn’t know it. I used men and they used me, there was a trade-off. But the price, or as you once said, the currency is immoral and irrational and ridiculous.

- I’m not scared of death. I will welcome it because I know there is no cure for all of these opportunistic invasions. The HIV can be managed, but that’s not the problem, it’s all of the opportunistics that are killing me.

- I want to talk with you about suicide.

- Dying, the process, scares me, the stages that the body goes through and what it does to the mind, I’m scared of that.

- I just had a birthday, and knowing that I’ll be dead soon, has me feeling overwhelmed.

- Does God love me even though I have misused my life and I have not been responsible for my health and the health of others? The whole Gay thing and God doesn’t bother me because I don’t believe in Man’s interpretation of God, and I think that all that God-talk is bullshit but I do believe that God wants us to love one another and to be responsible. As I say that, I feel convicted of a sin against others because if I loved others why would I be stupid enough to get naked with guys I barely know? I guess the question should be, why didn’t I love myself enough to prevent myself from getting naked with guys I barely knew? Why didn’t I love myself enough to demand that a man should love me as deeply as I love him? You often spoke about mutuality, and until now, I didn’t get it, and maybe I’m still not getting it but at least I’m aware that sex is meant to be a beautiful language and not a tool.

- Have I told you lately that I love you?

- I wish you had said yes in July, and you were wearing my ring.

- Why are men my age so fucked up about age? And yet, I don’t see age, I see the mind. At least, now I do, much clearer than last summer. Must I have to die to learn how to love or what love really is between two who share one heart and mind?

- I’m treating you like an authority on everything. I guess that’s how I have always seen you and maybe that’s why you are so alone. You scare the shit out of guys because your soul is so deep.

- I want to contact four of the five guys I had sex with to warn them, should I? I can do it online, they are still there. I wonder what symptoms they have? Maybe they only have Herpes or something manageable. The fifth guy, the one who really dumped this lethal dose on me, I want to kill him. What have I got to lose, I’m going to die anyway, why not kill him before I die, and I might be doing everyone a favor, by killing him!

- I’m thinking crazy. I’m not clear minded due to all the medications and I fear what I’ll be facing in the morning. They are going to burn my lungs to save my life, for at least a few months. I wonder if I’ll get a year out of this? Burn my lungs, do you know how filthy your lungs are? Do you know what happens to the body after it is burned? I’ll be pooling fluids and I guess I’ll be on an I.V. drip with more antibiotics. And Interferon is a bitch, it makes you so sick and I’m going to lose my thick blond hair. Will you still smile at me when I’m completely bald? I guess I’ll lose all of my body hair but they said that eventually all the hair will grow back and thicker. I’m just dreading the fevers, chills, aches, and vomiting.

- I’m going to have to give up my apartment. Mom and dad want me to come home. Do you know what it will be like for me to have to move back in with my parents? I don’t like the town they live in outside of Spokane. And there isn’t a hospital for miles. I’ll be isolated from my friends. Then again, I don’t know if I can have visitors once my immune system is destroyed by all those treatments. Then again, I’m not sure that I want my friends to see me like this. Will you visit me?

- Who cares for the caregiver?

- I’m sorry for talking only about me but I have not met anyone who listens with their heart and mind with such razor sharp precision. I remember an old friend who used to call you Scalpel because of your sharp edge. Is he still alive?

- Thank you for seeing me on such short notice.

- Thank you for helping me see this rationally and honestly and lovingly. I believe that you are one of God’s Angels walking amongst us bringing love within despair and clarity within my fog.

- May I hope to see you again?


[Excerpts from a conversation within Time]

21. John Stewart Mill: GOP Relativist


Contrary to what many people may believe and regardless of what Americans have been taught, the expression, “the end justifies the means” did not originate with Vladimir Lenin. However, as I reflect upon these last eight years of Republican dominance over the White House, and as I listen to the rhetoric puking forth from the “Party of No” and their lies of claiming a victory whenever a Democrat plan shows merit, I’m reminded of another fraud and trickster by the name of John Stewart Mill (JSM).

The Grand Oil Party (GOP) is currently rudderless and they are being exposed as a stolen party that is finally revealing the method to their madness, and that they are: The Self-Appointed God Squad, in the form of John Stewart Mill’s philosophy.

Mill believed in Utilitarianism, briefly, that means he, and his ilk, believed, and continue to practice, a “consequentialist” ethic: The moral (self-perceived or culturally relevant value being confused with that which is “moral”) rightness of an act is determined solely by its consequences.

Here is an example that I found online that best expresses Mill’s ability to be a trickster and it seems to coincide with the shenanigans, and criminal activity, of the Republicans under President Shrub. The protagonist in this story is clearly a utilitarian:


Mrs. O’Callahan instructed the artist painting her portrait to add to it a gold bracelet on each of her wrists, a strand of opulent pearls around her neck, large dripping ruby earrings, and a stunning diamond tiara.

The artist pointed out that that would be tantamount to lying.

Said Mrs. O’Callahan, “I want you to know that my husband is having an affair with a beautiful young blond, she is young enough to be his grand daughter, and after I die, I want her to go crazy looking for the jewelry.


The story of Mrs. O’Callahan and her portrait is amusing and I must admit that if I lived by a code of vengeance and only “feelings” (emotivism) then I would probably have done the same prior to my divorce from “J”. However, this method that Mrs. O’Callahan used for a justification could presumably be used to condone a variety of criminal and permissible acts, if the consequences were “felt” to be “good” enough. Please notice the emphasis on the “feelings” and the concept of what is “good enough”.

I’ll expand upon this methodology further by quoting a few militant religions, it’s like saying, “let’s torture and kill the body so that we can save the soul”. The end or goal is to “save” a soul hence torture is employed to extract a “confession” in “that” which the group perceives to be “god”.

Here’s another example for using “the ends justifies the means” method:

Mrs. Brevoort, a widow, was quietly sitting by the pool at her country club and she was feeling very horny. She had been a widow for several years and she really wanted sex with a man. Suddenly, she spotted a handsome man sunning himself. She slowly got up, and made her way over to him and said,

“Well, I don’t believe I’ve seen you here before.”

“Not likely,” the man said. “I’ve been in the penitentiary for thirty years.”

“Really? What for?”

“I murdered my first wife, and my second wife.”

“Ah!” Mrs. Brevoort said, “So, you’re single!”


The influential contemporary utilitarian Peter Singer often draws analogies between decisions that we all agree involve horrendous consequences and more seemingly benign decisions that he contends are ethically similar.

In one essay, he poses a situation in which one can earn money toward the complete purchase of a new car by selling a homeless child to a corporation that will harvest the child’s organs for transplants. Of course, Singer is assuming that there are several members within his audience who will hunt down, capture and then sell the street-dweller to achieve the ends of: organ harvesting while earning a new car. Singer believes that the end of harvesting benefits the recipient and the one who wants that new car, is entitled, so, “why not do it?”

There are many people who would be horrified by Singer’s story and his idea of usury, utilitarianism, however there are some people who view others as utilities. These people would see that the goal/end is just because it meets a need, and the profit margin in this act, would only further entice them (GOP). I’m quite aware that as I type this blog, it’s already happening in Third-World countries where they have nothing left to export but their organs. Singer further argues that any time one buys a new car in lieu of sending money to a charity that protects homeless children then the buyer is doing essentially the same thing: contributing toward the harvesting of organs. In essence, a person ceases to have worth, as a human being but is valued for “its” parts: the person becomes an object or a means to an end.

It’s an argument by analogy from a dramatic particular to a general moral pronouncement, like in this classic gag:


He: Would you sleep with me for a million dollars?

She: A million bucks? Wow! I guess I would.

He: How about for two dollars?

She: Get lost, buddy what do you think I am?

He: We have already established that. Now we are just haggling over the price.








Wednesday, March 18, 2009

21. Why Buy? Why Rent? The Debtors Dilemma



(thank you Mark Morford for the inspiration and may you continue to rejoice)

The horror stories have become endless as I sit here and reflect upon the attempted suicides and deep trauma associated with the blunt social psychological “death” of what once “was”.

Here is one example. A friend of mine saved for twenty years, she’s a highly qualified and educated nurse, to build her own dream home. It took two years to build and the “surprise” costs that kept popping up just ate away at her nest egg. Suddenly, after living in her dream house for only eight months, as of March 10th her “dream” slipped into a nightmare with many others, it was thrown up onto the auction block. She is homeless. I hope that one of her sons will take her in.

I don’t know where she is at the moment, and I do know where she works but she has chosen to remain silent in these last couple of weeks because she is in complete trauma. She can barely speak, sleep or eat.

In the midst of this economic scandal and terror, there are very few who are being indicted for crimes against the people, if anyone has been arrested at all while the “little” people sink and some die, we sure aren’t hearing about it. I can say this much, for the last eight years, many high ranking officials, developers and other businesses have committed the perfect crime, as they laugh all the way to the failing banks, that’s another story.

Here’s a small example. There’s an entire town that has collapsed, 750-home mega-development, that is actually sitting vacant, the most severe downturn in new-home construction in four billion years, it seems. Imagine, seeing all those eight to two year old homes that were once occupied, the best that the market could produce, at that time, sitting vacant with only the wild animals, criminals and the natural elements to keep them entertained. The loss just in that one of innumerable developments must be staggering, not to mention the private security forces to “protect” what is still viable, assuming that the crack-heads and meth-users don’t destroy them first. People are actually resorting to breaking into these houses to tear out the copper wiring etc. Then again, even the insurance companies aren’t backing these developments anymore as some houses suddenly go up in flames for a variety of moral and criminal reasons.

I’m writing this blog today because I do not believe in the American Dream. I remember at a doctoral level the in-depth discussion in the sociopsychology of: What is the American Dream?

I want to speak out about the Lie, and yes, upper case lettering, THE LIE that has been spun into a socially and culturally acceptable truth. If you want to talk about “truth”, this is my slap in the face of the Great American Lie: Owning your own home is, for the most part, just a little bit insane and the American Dream of ownership, is a lie.

I’m not an Economist, but I am very good in most of the Social Sciences and from what I’ve seen since 1986, and that’s a lot of years of watching, observing, participating in, and interpreting data, we are left with an unmistakable fact: at any given time, no more than about 50 percent of the American population should own their own homes, at the very most, and that’s the part of the American Dream that I support: the people who are able to afford the dream. Whereas, everyone else should either rent or consider living in a van, or they could share a place as in a group or community holding.

I remember when I bought my first home it was a gorgeous condo overlooking the Caloosahatchee Bay and River with a lovely southern exposure that eagerly accepted the warm, Caribbean scented breezes during the winter, and the brilliance of the summer sun. Thank God for Air Conditioning. Anyway, I chose it, my spouse wanted a northern exposure that made us stare at dark skies, he’s an idiot and that’s another story. The point is that my ex could not qualify for credit or for the mortgage, funny how exes seem to conveniently forget how good they had it when they were with you, but again, that’s another story.

It was 1991, and we had to put down ten percent of the total with numerous guarantees involving a variety of insurances etc. He and I put down twenty percent, I insisted, so that we could get a better lending rate. At that time, the condo was worth one hundred thousand, three years ago a condo beside it went for a third of a million, and now with the meltdown, as of today, that same condo is worth almost as much as it did in 1991. I digress.

It just seems to me that it makes more sense that if you don’t have the guaranteed income and the ability to at least put down twenty percent of the total, then why struggle with a mortgage and all the expenses that will go into maintaining your home?

Here’s something else that many of us don’t realize. Okay, so you now “own” your home, haven’t you realized that that’s still a BIG LIE? You will always be paying taxes, and I assure you, they do not remain fixed. I have a friend living in the city. In one year, that’s right, within twelve months her taxes went up one hundred percent! She appealed, and as of today, she has been given notice that there will be another twenty-five percent tax increase for the next quarter! So, not only is she struggling to pay her mortgage but also now she has increased taxes, increased sewer, water, and garbage fees. I could babble on about the roof work, plumbing, water leaks, furnace problems, property maintenance, and the ongoing battle over utilities that never drop in price.

Her house, in 1997, she bought it at: $150,000.00

Her mortgage was $550.00 / month

Her taxes used to be $1,200 a year, and then last year it went to $2,400.00 a year, and next year it should be approximately $3,200.00

Her city services are increasing every quarter, and she had to request “State Energy Assistance” to pay for her utilities for last month and the next two months.

We won’t discuss all the “other” expenditures ranging from new siding on the house, to prevent leaks, and the new roof etc. etc. etc.

It just makes more sense to rent then to struggle, especially when you don’t have a large guaranteed income. Many of my friends have suddenly realized that they will never really “own” their house due to all the expenditures that are city, county, and state based, and now some of them are saying to me, “it just seems to be fiscally irrational to buy a house, today.” Sorry, Einstein, you’re a little too late with that conclusion! Then again, I did try to warn them several years ago. Damn, I hate having to do that because I either endear myself to the other or they resent me when the truth arrives. Consequently, many people do not like me, and that’s another story.

Think about it, by buying a house it will actually do more harm than good to the economy, and there are millions of Americans who own right now who would've been far better off never buying at all (and not merely because all the foreclosures and lending debacles).

The question still stands: Could it be true? That maybe a large part of our current housing woes are at least somewhat attributable to this pathological need so many of us have to go into massive debt for the majority of our adult lives, just so you can have your own little box to destroy or rearrange or paint any color you want, so long as it's beige or gray or creamy eggshell white? Could be, could be?

I dare to question one of the Great American Commandments, the lie of ownership. I sincerely hope that this economic meltdown might be able to penetrate through this social pathology and teach millions of thick-skulled Americans a radical new perception of the truth: that buying a house is no more a prerequisite to achieving the American Dream than is, say, opening your own steakhouse or marrying a porn star or hoarding piles of stock in GM (and if you haven’t looked lately GM is tanking out, too, and let’s not discuss all of the STDs).

I have come to the conclusion that renting is often better than buying. That when you sit down and crunch the numbers and factor in all the taxes and dues and interest rates, maintenance fees, rodents, property challenges, trimming those huge trees up to code, and termites and cracked foundations and busted appliances and the cost of that new sewage line, shoveling the sidewalk according to code, the barking dogs next door, well, owning is far more of a hassle and a burden and a lifetime of stress than most people ever imagine.

And why don't we imagine it?

Why is owning a home still considered such a prize, such a cornerstone of what it means to be a victorious American? Simple: because that's what we're taught.



My family considers me a “loser” because I know longer “own” property in other words; I’m no longer part of “their” system of values and beliefs.

The shame of what we have done to our children. It seems that we have layered them and forced them to internalize the value of debt as something good. Think of it for a moment, how many times have we received both overt and subliminal messages that if you are going to be part of a “successful” society and culture, then that is absolutely dependent upon the following: Heterosexual nesting, and home ownership. I don’t know how many times I’ve heard the message that once you graduate from undergrad, you marry and start having babies (or, if you're feeling cynical, you add: Then get divorced, sell house, rent kids, die alone in Florida. Gosh, you're bitter).

However, if you follow the socially and culturally accepted directives well, good citizen, and then you will get your reward, straight from the government (IRS) and the approving church down the street. Tax incentives, write-offs, free credit, equity buildup, yes, imagine it, blessings from God Him/Herself. Choose to rent for your whole life and move around a bit, not be responsible for that exploding water tank, lousy heating system, cracked window, and never breed? You get nothing, sinner.

It's true. To defy any of these rules of what the majority perceive as a successful member of society is not only punishable by banishment from the Garden of Normalcy, but it's widely considered just a bit, immoral.

Live together without marriage? A sin.

Birth control? Still a sin (such a cute one, too).

Renting instead of buying? OK, not technically a sin, but to never feel a need to buy a home because you enjoy being fluid, not responsible for the property, and experimental and transitory? Sure. Something is clearly wrong with you. Better go live on a commune, hippie.

I can't count how many people that I've known over the years who were enjoying the hassle-free life that renting allows, but as soon as they get married and/or have a child, something very strange seems to take over their ability to “think”. I know you have seen it, too. It’s like, and I’m going to use a metaphor, their eyes get that peculiar look, and suddenly they decide they must move to suburban Ohio because, you know, "that's where we can afford to buy a house." See? Pathological.

(Of course, regarding the “married” folk, there are many other very important factors: space for the kids, tolerable schools, lower taxes, safer neighborhoods, fewer bullet casings and used condoms in the sidewalk, and so on. I get it. But this only explains the need to get out of the high crime areas. It still doesn't explain the urge to buy.)

Here's the new wisdom: Social demographics are changing. Family dynamics are shifting. The new data reveals that we are an increasingly fluid, itinerant culture, no longer nearly as rooted to specific towns and neighborhoods as we were 50 years ago.

The swell, rose-colored Norman Rockwell image of Americana, all porch swings and free parking and kids riding Big Wheels on the sidewalk next to neighbors who've lived on the street since the Eisenhower administration? Fading fast, if it ever really existed at all.

It's not easy to unpack. It's not easy to see the new perspective. For one thing, homes can be tremendously cool. I imagine designing your own to be the most gratifying form of self-expression, while providing a vital connection to place.

What's more, renting goes directly against our capitalist ethos. People like to own stuff, Americans especially so. Especially Americans who still have a sense of entitlement like no other species on the planet today except maybe Saudi sheiks and celebrity Chihuahuas and Mary J. Blige.

I've often felt the pull myself, have noticed that significant part of me that admires beautiful architecture and design, and often wants very much to invest in a beautiful space of my own and have the freedom to do with it what I want, some sort of gorgeous Dwell magazine fantasia that requires about three million and a revolving account at Gumps, or Roche Bobois.

But renting is certainly worth reconsidering. It's worth pondering that, in this time of tremendous upheaval and mandatory change, maybe we've been thinking about our identity, about the required ingredients for the American Dream, all wrong. And maybe owning a home, right along with buying an American car, is one of the great myths that are overdue for a revolution.










Sunday, March 15, 2009

20, Where's The Full Moon?


It’s no secret that a relationship is something that I do NOT want, but every now and then the world conspires to tell me that maybe that’s the dumbest thing I could ever want.


Why is it that most people who are in spousal relationships aren’t happy unless they have assimilated another person into their spousal paradigm? Then again, from what I’ve seen, there are sufficient amounts of people who can identify with, “misery loves company” or better yet, “sparkly is my favorite color”. There are my answers, and, that’s precisely what I’m trying to avoid: misery and sparkly!


I’m supposed to be packing and my phone has been ringing constantly with cries for help, from people who are having relationship troubles. One couple is having major trust issues, leading to aggressive arguments on a semi-regular basis with both of them calling me to discuss issues, but making me swear on my honor not to talk to the other one about it. Of course, when you swear, you swear on something important to you. My poor soul might need an exorcism at this rate.


Another couple swears black and blue that by opening up their relationship to include both known and secret sexual encounters over a year ago has saved it. May I just say, from a professional perspective, to the close, but external viewer, both their relationship and they as people, look somewhat like Meryl Streep and Goldie Hawn at the end of Death Becomes Her, something once beautiful used to live there, but now they are patched and filled with plaster and plastic, and re-sprayed around the edges. I might have the wrong end of the situation but I’m not coping very well as I watch them morbidly change because I care for them both dearly. Dead, is dead, and I’ve always had an aversion to watching a decaying corpse. Then again, let’s face it, an “open relationship” is just another way of saying, “my parents were emotionally absent, irresponsible and unaccountable for all my life, so let’s repeat the fun!” The amount of time and energy invested in escaping from emotional intimacy and chasing diversions from maturation could be invested in either (a) a good therapist, or (b) a good divorce lawyer.


The other situation is a love …. triangle, …. square… multiple sided shape, that is filled with obsession, lust, new sparks, and old flames. My philosophy is, if something’s burning that hot, don’t freaking touch it. However, if mental retardation is a family value, how dare I intervene with burn-gel?
When you’ve got all those people crying on your shoulder and whispering in your ear you can’t help but end up cynical. Now, dear reader, if you’ve survived all those mixed metaphors, bizarre likenesses and rants, you’ll understand why I feel like running away to a deserted island, alone. Especially when considering that they pull out the “friend card” hence they won’t pay me for my professional skills. On the other hand, what makes me assume that they want a cure?

The last thing I want in my life is any semblance from what’s in the above paragraphs, unless of course I value suicide, punishment and self-loathing.





Saturday, March 14, 2009

19. Rabbits and Reason

As usual, I had a great conversation with my best friend, and we discussed variations on a theme: the workings of the analytical mind and the rational mind. The former follows a pattern, or method to its logical but not necessarily rational conclusion whereas the latter is critical while using reason, as the person critiques one's healthiest options.

I love the following story.

The Wild Bunny Meets The Lab Bunny


A wild rabbit was caught and taken to a National Institutes of Health laboratory. Because he is a wild rabbit, when he arrives, he was scared of all the noises, torturous sounds, odors, colors and sensations foreign to his previous life.


He was suddenly befriended by a rabbit that had been born and raised in this lab.


One evening the wild rabbit noticed that his cage hadn't been properly closed and decided to make a break for freedom. He invited the lab rabbit to join him. The lab rabbit was unsure, as he had never been outside the lab, he knew that there was "something" out there but he had not thought or imagined that there would be anything of worth outside of the lab. However, the wild rabbit finally convinced him to "at least, give it a try."


Once they were free, the wild rabbit said, "Lab Rabbit, I'll show you the number-three best field in the whole world," and took the lab rabbit to a field full of lettuce. The variety was amazing.


After they had eaten their fill, the wild rabbit said, "Now I'll show you the number-two best field in the whole world," and took the lab rabbit to a field full of carrots. These were not just ordinary carrots but again, the variety was amazing.


After they had their fill of carrots, the wild rabbit said, "Now I'll show you the number-one best field that I've been saving for last, because you will be in heaven," and he took the lab rabbit to a lush meadow, full of flowers and sweet grasses, and everywhere they looked, there were beautiful female bunnies. "Indeed," thought the lab rabbit quietly to himself, "I must be in heaven" as the lab rabbit made nonstop lovemaking all night long.


As dawn was slowly beginning to break, the birds were sweetly singing to greet the sun, and the fragrance of a new beginning was slowly descending upon the lab rabbit's heart, something that the lab rabbit had never seen or heard before, he said, "Quick! I have to get back to the lab, now!"

"Why?" asked the wild rabbit. "I have shown you the number-three best field with as much lettuce the world can provide, the number-two best field with carrots of every variety, and the number-one best meadow with loving, caring ladies. Why do you want to go back to a life in the lab?"

The lab rabbit stared in disbelief, and with great certainty said, "Are you a fool? Can't you see! I can't help it. I'm dying for a cigarette!"



Question: what are the benefits of a methodical, controlled and organized life?

One of several intentions within my dissertation is to explore how an organization can pathologize its members, or not. There's an expression that is associated with the Russian Lab Scientist, Pavlov, and I'm certain he borrowed it from Plato's analogy of the Cave: "Can you think outside the cage?", or better yet, are you able to reason beyond the cave, or do we allow the cave to be an excuse or substitute, for not having a healthy life because the "lab" has an advantage over reason?







Tuesday, March 10, 2009

18. Goodbye, To All Who Have Struggled

Rest In Peace

Requiem Aeternam


Requiem æternam dona eis, Domine,
et lux perpetua luceat eis.
Te decet hymnus Deus, in Sion,
et tibi reddetur votum in Ierusalem.
Exaudi orationem meam;
ad te omnis caro veniet.
Requiem æternam dona eis, Domine,
et lux perpetua luceat eis.

Eternal rest grant unto them, O Lord,
and let perpetual light shine upon them.
A hymn becomes you, O God, in Zion,
and to you shall a vow be repaid in Jeruslem.
Hear my prayer; to you shall all flesh come.
Eternal rest grant unto them, O Lord,
and let perpetual light shine upon them.”


Saturday, March 7, 2009

17. H.R. and C.V.s, and People?

In this meltdown economy I've been trying to get a job, and I know it is a "bad" time to search however I'm fascinated by the lies, and if by chance, I do get a job then I'll be greatly relieved.

For example, the people who processed my C.V. belong to what's called: Human Resources.

By combining those two words, I believe that a contradiction is formed. Here's a quote:

"Human Resources: The objective of human resources is to maximize the return on investment from the organization's human capital and minimize financial risk. It is the responsibility of human resource managers to conduct these activities in an effective, legal, fair, and consistent manner."

Here is what's REALLY happening:

People are being treated as commodities or resources, and C.V.s and Resumes are being run through SOFTWARE by H.R. to see if the widget fits! There you have it, the contradiction, people are an "organization's capital".

No wonder I can't find a job, I'm NOT a "paper person" who knows how to describe himself in accordance with the language used by a H.R. software program!




Tuesday, March 3, 2009

14. Proof: Carrie and Seth


I seldom watch the series, "Sex And The City" but this evening's episode reminded me of several personal issues that prompted me to find a therapist many years ago. Given my family history, and other contributing systems, this evening's episode was about "attachment", as most of them are within that series, and for me it was about: how I attached to my former spouse.

I'll be brief.

Synopsis: Carie is having a few therapeutic sessions with an excellent Psychologist, "Dr. G.", and she meets a fellow patient by the name of Seth in the waiting room. She and Seth date throughout the episode and Carrie begins to think that "therapy is bogus, it's a scam".

Near the end of the episode, and after she and Seth make love for the first time, and it was in Carrie's bed, and the sexual encounter is very meaningful for Carrie, she asks:

Carrie: "Seth, I have been seeing Dr. G. for three sessions, and I'm beginning to think that therapy is bogus, how about you? How long have you been seeing Dr. G.?"

Seth: "I've been seeing Dr. G. for a year."

Carrie: "What do you think Dr. G. would think about us being together like this, tonight?"

Seth: "Dr. G. would consider us to be very bad patients."

Carrie: "Why are you seeing Dr. G?"

Seth: "Every time I sleep with a woman she means nothing to me once I've had sex with her, how about you?"

Carrie: "Choosing the wrong man!"

And that's when Carrie rolls over on her side, and thinks quietly, "Proof that therapy is not bogus, I really do need help!"

Carrie quits seeing Dr. G. because she would be too embarrassed to run into Seth in the waiting room now that Seth has had sex with Carrie, he has moved on to his next challenge. Meanwhile, Carrie goes hunting for a new therapist knowing that she really needs help because she chooses men who are "challenges".

That little episode really summed up my attraction and attachment to "J", the only difference is that I wasn't wise enough to (a) leave, (b) get help to figure out why I was attaching to challenges, (c) how did it happen, and (d) what could I do to stop/manage it. In essence, how did I become interested in someone who was disproportionately interested in me?

A friend of mine called those kind of men: projects, someone to work on.

I have a LARGE diagnostic book to name those kind of behaviors and very disturbing thoughts, and that's why tonight's episode brought a warm smile to my heart. As I reflect back, I can see that I have been able to manage my attraction to men who are "projects".

I remember telling a friend, who was interested in a "project", that I already have a full time job as a therapist so why would I want to leave work just to come home to work?

I used to be like "Carrie", and it's refreshing to see how I've grown since 1997!


Followers