Welcome!

My photo
"it's in the conversation that we are" - Gadamer

......it's by our actions that we are known

I may be reached at the following: ecgroup at comcast.net

Tuesday, November 18, 2008

5. But You Promised!

I’m aware that promises are not legally binding in this state, in that contract law is dependent upon an agreement that has been drawn up between two consenting adults, but seriously folks, when you make a promise, isn’t there some sense of responsibility and accountability?

We have a new colleague, just arrived in this city, and he was asking about whom within the sexually active community would not have a S.T.D. I told him that from within my patient caseload it would not be appropriate for us to discuss this question, and his reaction was, “it’s no big deal, and besides, if they aren’t still being seen by you then you can tell me.”

What part of ethics and morality courses did he sleep through?

For the sake of an argument, and overlooking the patient/practioner relationship, let’s just say that I’m not bound by any legal norms, the question that still begs to be addressed is: Aren’t we morally bound not to reveal that which we promised to hold in confidence?

My colleague believes that anything is open for discussion once the patient has left his practice. What constitutes leaving, maybe the patient is healthy and no longer requires attention hence his perceived departure? It seems that for the sake of convenience my colleague is willing to rework a promise.

My colleague is like most people, he is allergic to the following two words: responsibility and accountability.

I believe that I live within a very small minority of people who understand, and fully comprehend the concept of morality: your word is your bond, or you are dishonorable hence immoral. Other than moral philosophy, I suspect that we are observing a pattern of entitlement not only within an individual but also in social units. It’s like saying, “I want it therefore I must have it”. These people have either confused their “wants” with “needs” or it’s a matter of grandiosity. Within mental health, we would call this phenomenon: social narcissism.

If either making or keeping a promise is relative to how I feel, then it can’t be a promise by definition, and neither is the one making the promise psychologically mature enough to fulfill it. Regarding such people, I would further argue: BEWARE!










No comments:

Followers