Welcome!

My photo
"it's in the conversation that we are" - Gadamer

......it's by our actions that we are known

I may be reached at the following: ecgroup at comcast.net

Wednesday, March 18, 2009

21. Why Buy? Why Rent? The Debtors Dilemma



(thank you Mark Morford for the inspiration and may you continue to rejoice)

The horror stories have become endless as I sit here and reflect upon the attempted suicides and deep trauma associated with the blunt social psychological “death” of what once “was”.

Here is one example. A friend of mine saved for twenty years, she’s a highly qualified and educated nurse, to build her own dream home. It took two years to build and the “surprise” costs that kept popping up just ate away at her nest egg. Suddenly, after living in her dream house for only eight months, as of March 10th her “dream” slipped into a nightmare with many others, it was thrown up onto the auction block. She is homeless. I hope that one of her sons will take her in.

I don’t know where she is at the moment, and I do know where she works but she has chosen to remain silent in these last couple of weeks because she is in complete trauma. She can barely speak, sleep or eat.

In the midst of this economic scandal and terror, there are very few who are being indicted for crimes against the people, if anyone has been arrested at all while the “little” people sink and some die, we sure aren’t hearing about it. I can say this much, for the last eight years, many high ranking officials, developers and other businesses have committed the perfect crime, as they laugh all the way to the failing banks, that’s another story.

Here’s a small example. There’s an entire town that has collapsed, 750-home mega-development, that is actually sitting vacant, the most severe downturn in new-home construction in four billion years, it seems. Imagine, seeing all those eight to two year old homes that were once occupied, the best that the market could produce, at that time, sitting vacant with only the wild animals, criminals and the natural elements to keep them entertained. The loss just in that one of innumerable developments must be staggering, not to mention the private security forces to “protect” what is still viable, assuming that the crack-heads and meth-users don’t destroy them first. People are actually resorting to breaking into these houses to tear out the copper wiring etc. Then again, even the insurance companies aren’t backing these developments anymore as some houses suddenly go up in flames for a variety of moral and criminal reasons.

I’m writing this blog today because I do not believe in the American Dream. I remember at a doctoral level the in-depth discussion in the sociopsychology of: What is the American Dream?

I want to speak out about the Lie, and yes, upper case lettering, THE LIE that has been spun into a socially and culturally acceptable truth. If you want to talk about “truth”, this is my slap in the face of the Great American Lie: Owning your own home is, for the most part, just a little bit insane and the American Dream of ownership, is a lie.

I’m not an Economist, but I am very good in most of the Social Sciences and from what I’ve seen since 1986, and that’s a lot of years of watching, observing, participating in, and interpreting data, we are left with an unmistakable fact: at any given time, no more than about 50 percent of the American population should own their own homes, at the very most, and that’s the part of the American Dream that I support: the people who are able to afford the dream. Whereas, everyone else should either rent or consider living in a van, or they could share a place as in a group or community holding.

I remember when I bought my first home it was a gorgeous condo overlooking the Caloosahatchee Bay and River with a lovely southern exposure that eagerly accepted the warm, Caribbean scented breezes during the winter, and the brilliance of the summer sun. Thank God for Air Conditioning. Anyway, I chose it, my spouse wanted a northern exposure that made us stare at dark skies, he’s an idiot and that’s another story. The point is that my ex could not qualify for credit or for the mortgage, funny how exes seem to conveniently forget how good they had it when they were with you, but again, that’s another story.

It was 1991, and we had to put down ten percent of the total with numerous guarantees involving a variety of insurances etc. He and I put down twenty percent, I insisted, so that we could get a better lending rate. At that time, the condo was worth one hundred thousand, three years ago a condo beside it went for a third of a million, and now with the meltdown, as of today, that same condo is worth almost as much as it did in 1991. I digress.

It just seems to me that it makes more sense that if you don’t have the guaranteed income and the ability to at least put down twenty percent of the total, then why struggle with a mortgage and all the expenses that will go into maintaining your home?

Here’s something else that many of us don’t realize. Okay, so you now “own” your home, haven’t you realized that that’s still a BIG LIE? You will always be paying taxes, and I assure you, they do not remain fixed. I have a friend living in the city. In one year, that’s right, within twelve months her taxes went up one hundred percent! She appealed, and as of today, she has been given notice that there will be another twenty-five percent tax increase for the next quarter! So, not only is she struggling to pay her mortgage but also now she has increased taxes, increased sewer, water, and garbage fees. I could babble on about the roof work, plumbing, water leaks, furnace problems, property maintenance, and the ongoing battle over utilities that never drop in price.

Her house, in 1997, she bought it at: $150,000.00

Her mortgage was $550.00 / month

Her taxes used to be $1,200 a year, and then last year it went to $2,400.00 a year, and next year it should be approximately $3,200.00

Her city services are increasing every quarter, and she had to request “State Energy Assistance” to pay for her utilities for last month and the next two months.

We won’t discuss all the “other” expenditures ranging from new siding on the house, to prevent leaks, and the new roof etc. etc. etc.

It just makes more sense to rent then to struggle, especially when you don’t have a large guaranteed income. Many of my friends have suddenly realized that they will never really “own” their house due to all the expenditures that are city, county, and state based, and now some of them are saying to me, “it just seems to be fiscally irrational to buy a house, today.” Sorry, Einstein, you’re a little too late with that conclusion! Then again, I did try to warn them several years ago. Damn, I hate having to do that because I either endear myself to the other or they resent me when the truth arrives. Consequently, many people do not like me, and that’s another story.

Think about it, by buying a house it will actually do more harm than good to the economy, and there are millions of Americans who own right now who would've been far better off never buying at all (and not merely because all the foreclosures and lending debacles).

The question still stands: Could it be true? That maybe a large part of our current housing woes are at least somewhat attributable to this pathological need so many of us have to go into massive debt for the majority of our adult lives, just so you can have your own little box to destroy or rearrange or paint any color you want, so long as it's beige or gray or creamy eggshell white? Could be, could be?

I dare to question one of the Great American Commandments, the lie of ownership. I sincerely hope that this economic meltdown might be able to penetrate through this social pathology and teach millions of thick-skulled Americans a radical new perception of the truth: that buying a house is no more a prerequisite to achieving the American Dream than is, say, opening your own steakhouse or marrying a porn star or hoarding piles of stock in GM (and if you haven’t looked lately GM is tanking out, too, and let’s not discuss all of the STDs).

I have come to the conclusion that renting is often better than buying. That when you sit down and crunch the numbers and factor in all the taxes and dues and interest rates, maintenance fees, rodents, property challenges, trimming those huge trees up to code, and termites and cracked foundations and busted appliances and the cost of that new sewage line, shoveling the sidewalk according to code, the barking dogs next door, well, owning is far more of a hassle and a burden and a lifetime of stress than most people ever imagine.

And why don't we imagine it?

Why is owning a home still considered such a prize, such a cornerstone of what it means to be a victorious American? Simple: because that's what we're taught.



My family considers me a “loser” because I know longer “own” property in other words; I’m no longer part of “their” system of values and beliefs.

The shame of what we have done to our children. It seems that we have layered them and forced them to internalize the value of debt as something good. Think of it for a moment, how many times have we received both overt and subliminal messages that if you are going to be part of a “successful” society and culture, then that is absolutely dependent upon the following: Heterosexual nesting, and home ownership. I don’t know how many times I’ve heard the message that once you graduate from undergrad, you marry and start having babies (or, if you're feeling cynical, you add: Then get divorced, sell house, rent kids, die alone in Florida. Gosh, you're bitter).

However, if you follow the socially and culturally accepted directives well, good citizen, and then you will get your reward, straight from the government (IRS) and the approving church down the street. Tax incentives, write-offs, free credit, equity buildup, yes, imagine it, blessings from God Him/Herself. Choose to rent for your whole life and move around a bit, not be responsible for that exploding water tank, lousy heating system, cracked window, and never breed? You get nothing, sinner.

It's true. To defy any of these rules of what the majority perceive as a successful member of society is not only punishable by banishment from the Garden of Normalcy, but it's widely considered just a bit, immoral.

Live together without marriage? A sin.

Birth control? Still a sin (such a cute one, too).

Renting instead of buying? OK, not technically a sin, but to never feel a need to buy a home because you enjoy being fluid, not responsible for the property, and experimental and transitory? Sure. Something is clearly wrong with you. Better go live on a commune, hippie.

I can't count how many people that I've known over the years who were enjoying the hassle-free life that renting allows, but as soon as they get married and/or have a child, something very strange seems to take over their ability to “think”. I know you have seen it, too. It’s like, and I’m going to use a metaphor, their eyes get that peculiar look, and suddenly they decide they must move to suburban Ohio because, you know, "that's where we can afford to buy a house." See? Pathological.

(Of course, regarding the “married” folk, there are many other very important factors: space for the kids, tolerable schools, lower taxes, safer neighborhoods, fewer bullet casings and used condoms in the sidewalk, and so on. I get it. But this only explains the need to get out of the high crime areas. It still doesn't explain the urge to buy.)

Here's the new wisdom: Social demographics are changing. Family dynamics are shifting. The new data reveals that we are an increasingly fluid, itinerant culture, no longer nearly as rooted to specific towns and neighborhoods as we were 50 years ago.

The swell, rose-colored Norman Rockwell image of Americana, all porch swings and free parking and kids riding Big Wheels on the sidewalk next to neighbors who've lived on the street since the Eisenhower administration? Fading fast, if it ever really existed at all.

It's not easy to unpack. It's not easy to see the new perspective. For one thing, homes can be tremendously cool. I imagine designing your own to be the most gratifying form of self-expression, while providing a vital connection to place.

What's more, renting goes directly against our capitalist ethos. People like to own stuff, Americans especially so. Especially Americans who still have a sense of entitlement like no other species on the planet today except maybe Saudi sheiks and celebrity Chihuahuas and Mary J. Blige.

I've often felt the pull myself, have noticed that significant part of me that admires beautiful architecture and design, and often wants very much to invest in a beautiful space of my own and have the freedom to do with it what I want, some sort of gorgeous Dwell magazine fantasia that requires about three million and a revolving account at Gumps, or Roche Bobois.

But renting is certainly worth reconsidering. It's worth pondering that, in this time of tremendous upheaval and mandatory change, maybe we've been thinking about our identity, about the required ingredients for the American Dream, all wrong. And maybe owning a home, right along with buying an American car, is one of the great myths that are overdue for a revolution.










No comments:

Followers