I've been listening to the discussion that went on in the State Senate, prior to the passage of a bill that would criminalize any violent act against Homosexuals as a Hate Crime, and the bill also stated that no one in the State will be able to discriminate on the basis of sexual orientation. The arguments in the Senate seem to gravitate towards either exclusion of people as based upon religious values and belief systems or inclusion of people with an insistence on civil rights for everyone, but both sides ultimately rest their arguments on their assumptions about the morality of Homosexuality.
Typically, we get hung up on the wrong questions - important ones, to be sure, but not the relevant ones.

Certainly, if Homosexuality is moral, then Homosexuals should be protected from discrimination in housing, employment, medical care, education and insurance, at the very least.
But what if Homosexuality is not moral?
Those who stood against the passage of the bill were concerned that it legalized or legitimized something they thought was immoral because it conflicted with their religious values and beliefs, and, in some cases, that we had an obligation to protect society from, so I want to briefly look at those arguments.
First, it doesn't take much imagination to realize that many Heterosexual relationships are immoral, some of them are even marriages.
For example:
(a) Joe doesn't love Joan, she's just his trophy wife, and Joan doesn't love Joe, either, she's just after his money
(b) Joe uses Joan for sexual gratification while thinking of other women, and Joan will also fantasize about other men while having sex with her husband, Joe
(c) Joe married Joan for social status
(d) Joan needed health insurance so she married Joe to receive benefits from his employer
(e) Joe wants children so that he can prove that he's a "man" and his wife Joan wants children so that she can be popular with the other women in the community
(f) Joe and Joan occasionally look for a third sexual partner to liven up their married sex life or they use porn as a distraction from each other
(g) Joan always wanted a "White Church Wedding" with all the trimmings so she marries Joe in the church, and both seldom attend, but image means everything
(h) Joe always brings Joan an expensive gift when he returns home from his out of state business meetings, and Joan overlooks the lipstick on his collar
(i) Joe runs everything through Joan's business for a tax deduction, and Joan "employs" Joe even though he doesn't work for her company
(j) Joan isn't allowed to go out with her friends but Joe and the "boys" never miss their various sports' gatherings, both on television and outside
(k) Joan isn't allowed to use birth control or protection but Joe often has extramarital sex without protection
(l) Joe prefers his "woman" to be "barefoot and pregnant" and Joan is not allowed to have an education
(m) Joan lives in fear of Joe's displeasure
etc.
These are only a few of the immoral horror stories that I have heard from my married Heterosexual couples.
The fact that they entail sexual relations between a man and a woman doesn't make them moral, yet we don't have a big problem with discrimination and prejudice against people who are involved in immoral Heterosexual marriages, so why do we have that problem with people we think are involved in immoral Homosexual relationships?

It seems to me, then, that it's not really over the morality of relationships at all - else the same people who are against legislation that makes it illegal to discriminate against Homosexuals would be championing laws against immoral Heterosexual marriages, as well!

No, it's over the particular sexual conduct of others.
But, again, let me bite the bullet and assume for a moment that monogamous Homosexuality is immoral, even in the most loving, long term, committed relationships. Even IF it's immoral, discrimination can't be justified because even people who do bad things ........in fact, even people who do the worst kinds of things in our society.......have rights that should and must be protected.

Imagine the worst immoral person you can think of, and then ask yourself if it would be moral to enact legislation that allows that individual to be tortured, deprived of food and water, to be housed in a prison without adequate hygiene or medical care, or any of the other immoral things we might imagine or even want, sometimes, to do to them. It's not moral to do these things, even to a person who is acting immorally, anymore than it's moral to discriminate against Homosexuals, even IF what they are doing is immoral.
It's that thing about two wrongs do not make it right.
So, what I'm having difficulty seeing is the kind of thinking that starts out by claiming that Homosexuality is immoral and works through to the conclusion that we should allow discrimination and prejudice against people who do immoral things.
Discrimination and prejudice are not moral, whether Homosexuality is, or not!

The question of discrimination against people who are Gay and Lesbian IS a civil rights issue and that's all it is.......the question of whether or not Homosexuality is moral, is a different question and issue, altogether, and religious values and beliefs do not belong in the Senate because once a Government entertains behaviors as based upon religious values and beliefs, then not even the "married Heterosexual" community will be protected.

No comments:
Post a Comment