Two former patients died gruesome deaths because (a) not all pain can be “managed”, and (b) one man in particular was not prepared for his death, and consequently he was unaware of how dying in stages can be utterly grotesque. They each had a resilient spirit and were willing to explore new ideas, but it seemed one in particular understood what Honor and Devotion means.
When I first moved here and began my practice there was an atmosphere of openness, acceptance, tolerance, and especially a yearning for wisdom as opposed to knowledge amongst most of my patients who desired “analysis”. I was surprised by how open many people went to psychoanalysis as correlated with end-stage development, especially in this city that has been terribly maligned for being conservative and “backward”.
One of the recently deceased first became my patient when I arrived due to complications with his spouse of five years. These two men were having difficulty planning for their financial future. Each was established in good paying professions but they were arguing more frequently, and they wanted to regain the harmony they once had. Have you noticed that what could be considered insignificant in a relationship has the potential to indicate something “other”, like an underlying, unresolved issue that has quietly festered for years but has taken on a variety of presentations?
Let’s call my patient, Paul. He loved Peter without reservation, and still after five years, both he and Peter were having marital problems that were often caused by heated discussions about their finances. It wasn’t that they lacked income rather they had the opposite problem. Each gentleman had a sumptuous six-figure salary.
Paul wanted to invest for their future, and Peter wanted to buy the latest toy. That last sentence basically summed up their values and conflicts, hence their problems arrived into my office.
To be brief, Paul ran a company with generosity as his motto, and then there was Peter. He was a man who only wanted to play without regard, responsibility and accountability. How he and Paul differed were like night and day.
I became a psychoanalyst specializing in Thanatology and Palliative therapy because I deeply care about people and their suffering. I had a theory, once, it went something like this: if a person gets to know himself well enough, and becomes aware of whom he is, then good health, a release from repetitive behaviors that lead to suffering, and moral behaviors should follow. I’m re-thinking that thesis.
Yes, I'm sure that I had my own "selfish" reasons for pursuing this field- definitely wanting to understand myself better, to ease my own pains, and maybe even searching for validation as a person worthy of the gratitude of others. I admit it. When someone pays me a compliment, for reasons of shame, I shrivel up inside because my self-worth is deplorable. Also, when I’m loved, I feel dreadfully unworthy and yet eternally grateful. As for the profession I chose, it’s true, I really do love, and care, regardless of my protests. I couldn't do this work if I didn't care and I didn't hold myself to the highest standards that I can possibly reach in the work that I do. Compromising my values has never been something I could do without personal strife. That is why each day it feels like a physical assault as I listen to how people abuse each other, take the other for granted, the lack of regard, the misinterpretation of love, and how rampant usury has become.
Paul had a remarkable social conscience unlike many politicians. He cared. He wanted to invest in his business so that there will be a company ten years from now still employing people. Paul also felt guilty for not doing enough for the poor and unemployed and that’s why he and Peter would argue about finances. Peter wanted to play, whereas Paul wanted to guarantee men and women a secure future. I have often wondered why a person such as Paul would marry a guy like Peter. I know that I can offer up a text book formula based on Attachment Theory, but still, because of our intimate conversations, deep down, Paul “knew” that he should not be with Peter, but still, Paul was loyal and devoted, he stayed.
Peter had other ideas. Unlike Paul, he would enjoy private vacations and business trips, alone. At first this did not bother Paul, until one morning when Paul was sorting the laundry and he found in Peter’s pants’ pocket a cocktail napkin with a hotel room scribbled on it in someone else’s handwriting.
Paul believed that he reacted like most spouses given the identical situation. He stood, stared, felt his mouth run dry, a heart that beat uncontrollably as shock’s icy grip crawled down his spine and through his gut as panic squeezed his lungs.
Peter had departed earlier for an adjacent city on business. His return was planned for the following night, and so he could not be reached while traveling at high altitudes.
What does one do when he finds out that his spouse may have sexually cheated? Which is more painful for Paul, knowing about the physical encounter or the psychological adultery? How is one to know if this was a first time, or is this napkin just something innocent? When did these trespasses first occur and how long have they been occurring? Why didn’t Paul see it, or them? Was there anything to “see”? Was he sure that what he was assuming, to be true, is true, or is disorientation the result of suspicions long suppressed? One whisper of doubt, and suspicion can undo years of fidelity, stability, security, and safety, but is that “whisper” credible? And, if it is, how did they as a couple move from devotion to licentiousness, depravity and excess? Both were using the same language when they spoke their identical wedding vows, how could one vow be interpreted differently from the other? When did Peter begin his change? What was Paul’s part in this story? They lived together, spoke the same language and yet values were not necessarily shared even though they shared the same bed.
By that afternoon, Paul was pacing in my waiting room as the receptionist called his name. He sat beside me on my office sofa, and he couldn’t speak. His face was ashen white, grey; his large blue eyes had shrunk and were caressed by large red and pink pillows of sagging skin. He could not stop crying. He felt like my sofa was a safe place to be as he desperately tried to choke out the details. He showed me the napkin.
Psychological pain is the hardest to deal with. There are medications for bone-pain, cellular-neuro-connected pain, but emotional trauma, the loss of one’s emotional well-being is very difficult to address. Paul was deeply injured. His pain was inconsolable. He insisted that he would phone Peter while being in my presence. Paul confronted Peter over the phone about his suspicions and the new-found napkin.
Peter was silent.
Paul was in deeper shock to hear nothing but silence.
Peter sighed, and then casually said, “When I get home I’ll tell you about him” and then Peter hung up.
Have you ever seen someone’s life signs just suddenly, stop? Paul looked like the expression: a deer in the headlights! He couldn’t move. I suppose the only difference is that the headlights had already left heavy and wide tire tracks over his soul. There were a thousand things he wanted to do but moving his body was not one of them. Every fiber of his being was rejecting life and that’s when he fell to the ground, clutching his cell phone while holding his gut and in great agony through clenched teeth he could only utter the word “No”.
There was much that I was thinking and feeling as I wrapped my arms around Paul. He would not get up off the floor, so I held him. It was one of those experiences where unless you had been there, well, you just can’t make this shit up. It was surreal. After all these years, and everything that they had experienced together, that’s all Peter had to say.
Paul kept phoning Peter, but to no avail. Paul knew that he would have to wait through the next 30 hours before he could get the truth from Peter. And now, Paul’s pain was worse than ever. He couldn’t talk other than mutter a few sentences that really didn’t make much sense. I allowed him to stay in my office for as long as he needed a safe space. I saw patients in other rooms. With Paul’s consent, we managed to put together a team of friends to be with him over these next 30 hours. Needless to say, the hours seemed like months.
When Peter finally arrived home, he admitted to numerous adulteries both physical and psychological, and oddly enough his recurring statement was, “it’s no big deal, it’s only sex”. I think that each time when he said that phrase, I watched part of Paul’s heart, die.
The truth was out. Paul was now living with a nameless pain that was exhausting, frightening, and intense enough to make him stay in bed for weeks. He was on “Suicide Watch” for a month, we each took our turn. During the chaos of trying to find ways to repair Paul, it was interesting how Peter lacked any feelings of responsibility, remorse, or guilt. Also, Peter never once suggested that he find another place to live rather he insisted that “if Paul doesn’t like my private life then he should move out of our bedroom and sleep in the guest room.”
Peter: No Remorse; No Guilt; No Sadness; No Accountability; No Responsibility; Bold; Arrogant; Inconvenienced by Paul. That sums up what the following months were like at their house. It had ceased to be a home by now. Friends and family members were all disoriented by this event, and even when it came time for Paul and Peter to die, Peter’s death was lonely.
Yes, Peter had brought home several “gifts that keep on giving”. The first one to make its appearance was Esophageal HPV with all the pain and discomfort associated with that virus. Paul was first to become knowingly symptomatic. Peter’s scrotum began to show signs weeks later. From that moment on, both of these men would fight one onset of either a single disease or a cluster of invasions that would leave them in a further weakened state.
Paul would not divorce Peter, and Peter never did ask for forgiveness as they continued to share their sizeable house. Paul would say, “I married him in sickness and in health, and I’m a man of my word”. His family honored Paul by treating Peter with respect even though there was always an unspoken tension that Peter was a murderer.
As for Peter, he would often say, “oh, loosen up, ya gotta have fun!” And of course, such a statement as this would only further sour the family’s regard for Peter because by this time, everyone was watching two beautiful men, slowly, painfully, and cruelly, die.
Finally, when viruses and bacteria as associated with time and the frailty of our bodies eventually take over, then there’s nothing much left to do but prepare to say goodbye. Paul and Peter sold their house, and many other things that they had collected, and Paul chose to be with his mother, family, and friends. Whereas Peter took the money and went on long cruises, sex-vacations for HIV + people, and eventually returned to live in an apartment so that he could continue his social romp on the various online sites.
I have often wondered what would have happened if Peter and his sexual buddies had a different psychology other than “fun associated with usury”? What would have happened if Peter had married his equal? Why were these two men both speaking English but not communicating?
Peter died long after Paul because he chose to live out his final days in a hospital. When he arrived at Sacred Heart with his numerous “gifts”, his body slowly turned into something bionic with tubes and machinery buying seconds of fleeting time. The nurse said that when he died, he was alone, he rarely had visitors, if any, and most of his human contact was a television that was left on continuously.
Paul died first. It was like a mighty wind had blown throughout that wintery night and by morning, the ground was deep, white, and soft with a fresh, clean snowfall. As the sun was rising and the flurries were beginning to rest for the beginning of a new day, a final gust of wind blew over the house and his mother thought she heard a man’s soft voice say, “come home, Paul, we are waiting for you”.
To this day, Paul’s mother still tells the story of how she was able to say farewell to her gracious son. And much to everyone’s surprise, his last time on this planet was spent during one of his most cherished moments: listening to a snow storm whirl and dance through the trees around his mother’s home, and then suddenly, a gentle pause, as he looked up toward where a man’s voice could be heard. Some say it was only the wind, but his mother believes that God gives breath to all things, and the wind called him by name.


No comments:
Post a Comment