Welcome!

My photo
"it's in the conversation that we are" - Gadamer

......it's by our actions that we are known

I may be reached at the following: ecgroup at comcast.net

Tuesday, June 16, 2009

41. Locals: You Are Almost One Of Us

I have lived and practiced in diverse environments, and while living in this current city for the past twelve years, it seems that the majority of the local inhabitants are sharply committed to sustaining and maintaining the social concept of “tribalism”. The “locals”, as I refer to them, are comfortably predisposed to in-group / out-group demarcations as a social value.

Please also know that within these social and cultural demarcations there are a variety of guarded behaviors that support the infrastructure of maintaining the value of "us" vs. "them". I believe that what’s most disturbing about this activity is that the vast majority of these negatively biased people actually cherish their ignorance of the “other”, or newcomer.

I’ll be blunt: they don’t know, that they are doing it, rather it’s part of the fabric of their “grouping”; they don’t care or want to know about changing their tribal identity, and worse yet, through their values of exclusion and resistance they further perpetuate the social psychological crime of soul murder. God help the people who have been categorized as being “not one of us” by the locals, and I won’t even begin to discuss the immorality of their behaviors and how they practice the following: moral relativism, and situation ethics, that only further enhance their tribalism: closed systems. What a vicious cycle!

I’ll give two examples of “soul murder” from a Social Psychological perspective even though I would love to discuss this phenomenon from the perspective of Community Psychiatry:

Case One:

A woman and her husband, and twin sons, moved here from Phoenix eighteen years ago. The children were only two months old at the time. They lived about six houses down from their Protestant Church in a nicely aged neighborhood. She spent EVERY Wednesday night at Bible Study; Thursday nights were always taken up with choir practice; Saturdays were either Bake Sales, meetings etc. or Summer Vacation Bible School, and she and her family NEVER missed going to church Worship Services on Sunday morning, and following that they would spend an hour sharing coffee and lunch in the basement of her church with her fellow members, and with punctuality she rarely missed making hospital visits on Sunday afternoon with the Elders / Deacons of her church. Monday nights were randomly spent at church Board meetings or working on various church projects.

One day, after living amongst her fellow parishioners for eighteen years, she mentioned during coffee hour after their Sunday morning Worship Service that she and her husband were considering moving back to Phoenix because her two sons had left for university in that city. Her Pastor’s response, along with the large group who were enjoying coffee with her that day, said, “Please don’t leave, you are almost one of us!”

WTF!!!

Let’s call her “Sheila”. When she heard those words, she felt an icy chill creep across her body as she began to sweat and experience chest pains unknowingly she was experiencing her first panic attack. Upon arriving home, she collapsed on the sofa and her husband immediately phoned me. By that late afternoon we had to admit her onto the Psych. Floor because she could not manage her anxiety, grief, shock, chest pain, and headaches that suddenly affected her life.

Imagine being told, after investing your life, and your family’s identity for eighteen years into a “church”, that the members then exclaim with such certainty, “Please don’t leave, you are almost one of us”. Which begs the question: what the fuck does it take to be accepted and to experience a sense of belonging within such groups? Especially, from within an organization that publicly preaches and promotes a Gospel of love when in reality their behaviors are incongruent with that which is professed.

Sheila was experiencing her first encounter with organizational contradictions, and social dissonance. The policies and the procedures of the organization are contradictory and irrational to that which they proclaim hence policies and procedures are incongruent.

Sheila had a complete break from reality, and it took years to help her work toward acceptance and recognition of how closed systems can “murder” the soul, and she needed to learn how to “see” that there are people who only know who they are by whom they exclude! Further, she had to learn "how" she attached to a group that practices reward and punishment, and "why" she would be attracted to a group of people who value only "in-groups".


Case Two

Steve moved here fifteen years ago and practices medicine. Professionally, his encounters with the “locals” are either on a patient or colleague basis but the concept of making “friends” or establishing enduring “friendships” with many of the “locals”, are not actualized. Of the many indicators that set him apart, it is obvious that he was born in Alabama because of his thick Southern accent.

For example, when Steve is in a bar or visiting someone’s house he is often treated as though he is invisible because (a) the locals have no current need of his services, and (b) he is perceived as being a threat to their social value system due to his appreciation of higher education hence his willingness to encourage others to “go back to school” which is perceived as being counter-culture.

Steve’s social psychological fracture occurred when he was sitting amongst other local gay men, and they began talking about an upcoming summer party as though he was not sitting amongst them. An invitation was not offered, even though he had treated several of these men in the past, and knew them all, and neither was he included in the conversation.

Steve said, “it was like I was invisible as they talked through me, around me, and over me while they physically avoided making eye contact and touch. I felt abandoned and rejected, it was as though the welcome mat was pulled out from under me and as I fell, no one offered a helping hand. That’s when I realized that this was nothing new rather they had been treating me this way for years and it has been happening constantly regardless of the location in this city. They were making it obvious that I wasn’t ‘one of them’, and my heart sank into despair.”

Steve had to learn, through his pain, how NOT to seek acceptance from people with impaired and malfunctioning social interactions. It’s identical to saying: not only do these people demonstrate a social disability, but there’s also a social inability to willingly practice inclusion.



Here is how I explained Social Dissonance within groups as a learned behavior, and Closed Systems as a social value through Stage Theory (this is only one, of several, approaches that could be used):

(1) I am part of Group X

(2) Group X is my group

(3) Group X members knowingly and/or unconsciously recognize group memberships

(4a) Group X is better than all other groups (association through high worth / power)

Or

(4b) Group X is less than all other groups (association through low worth / victim)

(5) Group cohesiveness occurs as based upon randomly alternating between the following values: 4a / 4a4b / 4b

(6) Groups A through Z excluding Group X are watched with suspicion and distrust hence “other” is relegated to invisibility/denial/avoidance, and resistance and/or not a valued status

(7) Group X when it is clearly the strongest, largest and/or most favored group, projects the need for in-group / out-group

(7a) intense in their need for “other” (competitor/enemy) and/or self-victimization

(8) Group X becomes inebriated in their self-absorption

(9) Group X as a consequence will lack the capacity for out-group empathy

(10) Group X self-creates further arguments and beliefs to advance the tribal phenomenon of self-absorption at its core and reinforce the closed system

(11) Group X: Back to origins – cycle from (1) to (11) is maintained and to break from this cycle is infrequent, at best.



I asked a local-native the following: What does acceptance and belonging mean to you?

His reply:

“I was born and raised here. I went to college in this city, and now I’m really involved in working at different bars while also being a nurse part-time. My family and all the other families I was raised with, and into which I was born, have just assumed that we [locals] are better than others. We believe that our city, although limited for gay people, has a better living standard and because we all know each other we can trust each other so in a way we feel and know we are superior than most others. It’s really odd because we resent newcomers but we need their business. It’s odd because we shit on our city, we say that we hate it here, but no one ever actually moves away for long, and if they do move, we all know that they will move back, but the person who is new and just moves into our city and area, well, he better not say anything negative about our city and area because we will agree with them to their face but inwardly we will hate him for reminding us that we live in a dumpy city. Again, we really resent the coastal cities but we act like our city is better and even I know that that is not true. This is a city that we love to hate and most times we hide our discontent and anger from ‘outsiders’. To even suggest that our city and friends have flaws comparable to others is to engage in a losing battle because we don’t want others to know that we know, and yet these things are obvious, aren’t they? I guess what we [locals] all share in common is our self-loathing and hatred of our city but we feel superior because of it. Wow, now that’s a mind fucking contradiction. And yet we purposely create ‘out-groups’, as you call them, it’s like we try to find out what town on this side of the state do you live in or are from or what section of the city were you born and lived in and then we harm each other because you aren’t from ‘South Hill’ or some other snobby neighborhood, and we just keep passing the anger around, and around. Now that you have asked this question and after a little bit of thought, I guess I have to ask, why would anyone from ‘outside’ want to belong? Then again, I guess you are right, we all have acceptance and belonging needs so I guess we withhold our acceptance because we hate ourselves, and our lives in this city, so we pass on the pain as a way of knowing who we are and making sure that outsiders will always know who they are, they are not one of us!”



I asked a third generation native to this area, the following question: Have you seen any changes, positive or negative, regarding acceptance, belonging, and group-formation in this city as associated with tribalism?

He said,

“Many of us complain endlessly about the unfairness of affirmative action in undermining ‘merit-based’ achievement -- similarly we owe our entire careers to our moms and dads. I went away to get my doctorate and both my brother and I have ‘inherited’ our family’s fortune and status. My parent’s money helped me start my practice and my brother’s law firm needed my family’s social contacts. In many ways we don’t like to talk about it but there’s a lot of nepotistic interconnections that are easily maintained because we all know who is “new” and who is local. But that’s all changing, much to the anger of many because there are more people moving in from California, Oregon and New York who have discovered how the cost of living here is so low in comparison to their original locations. I have to say that I have seen how merit-based accomplishments are replacing the good-ole-boy’s connections and family connections in this city. Just the other day I heard a fourth generation land developer, and I have known he and his family all of my life, he argued that ‘my group, the one I was born into and trained to love, is being victimized and treated so badly by all of this new blood coming into our city’. I want you to know that his words sent a chill into my heart because his entitlement or narcissism only perpetuates in-group self-victimization and persists even when their group historically occupied and continues to occupy positions of power and influence far disproportionate to their actual numbers. In other words, my childhood friend is living a lie and he doesn’t even know it!”



I suspect that one of the many cohesion factors within our local presentation of tribalism: in-group / out-group, is not only based upon being self-absorbed but also there’s a delusional factor involved. It seems that until many of these biased in-group members personally experience the pain of rejection, abandonment and shunning, perhaps then they may break from their delusion of power and control through in-group dominance.

It’s like saying until I have a gay child then as a parent I’ll maintain and sustain the negative prejudice against “those queers” because there aren’t any “queers” in our city, only the ones who moved here!

Does becoming personally affected by the isolationist ideology they advocate cause positive change?

Sheila’s Pastor, a third generation local, deviated from his social conservative dogma and in-group bias to become a leading advocate of welcoming new people into the city because his daughter married a man from New Jersey. Until this happened, he was oblivious to how he supported and was entrenched within tribalism.

Steve’s "local friends" are still shunning some of the most dynamic, brilliant, and pleasant “newcomers” rather than abandon their behaviors of punishment and exclusion. Also, it seems that when a tribal-local has moved away and returned, he falls back into the role and model of in-group / out-group hostilities even though he had experienced what it was like to be an alien in a strange land.

It appears that the re-presentation value of Group X is not only their identity but it has become their worth-value.

And yet, I know of a small amount of former Group X members who had to learn either through disease or some other tragedy, how to be hospitable and welcoming once they returned from their adventures abroad, but do not be fooled, many, even within this new rank of Group X returning members, still crave for the acceptance of Group X members, but with a “twist”, they are either completely or partially open to welcoming the stranger in their midst unlike the original Group X members.

Briefly, it seems that many, not all, appear to advocate their closed system values and views up until the point that it begins to adversely affect not only others within that in-group, but also themselves. I find it fascinating that the only victims they ever see are themselves, and the only unfairness they recognize is to their own group, the only perspective they are capable of understanding is the tribalistic ones that is drummed into their heads from birth.

Does chronological age have any positive impact upon our local tribalism?

At first I thought it would, however chrononicity is not a factor to awareness. If someone wishes to argue that there’s a correlation between assumed and perceived behaviors as associated with adolescence that continues within an age related linear direction, then I would agree that one of the defining attributes of early adolescence is to be incapable of seeing the world through any lens other than total self-centeredness, self-absorption and empathy-free self-obsession. Therefore, as the members of Group X age, their social and mental capacities seem to remain adolescent as previously described.

If you watch for it (principally though not only) in local tribal discourse, you will see that this is really the central theme animating most of what they say and do:

My Group X is superior

My Group X is victimized and treated unfairly

The misery and suffering that My Group X inflicts on far less powerful groups is irrelevant and always justifiable

Even the people or groups who move here and we shun, reject, ignore, abandon, snub, and treat harshly, are the ones victimizing us


My summation is: The locals, as a large social unit rarely, and perhaps never, truly advance beyond the adolescent stage of tribalistic self-absorption and it's amazing how completely that lies at the core of most of what they believe and argue.



No comments:

Followers