Welcome!

My photo
"it's in the conversation that we are" - Gadamer

......it's by our actions that we are known

I may be reached at the following: ecgroup at comcast.net

Monday, June 29, 2009

49. Martha Stout: Larry Needs To Go

I was reading Martha Stout (2005) again because I’m writing up a particular case study for a colleague regarding how a sociopathic man was able to evade being properly diagnosed while under my colleague’s care. Actually, it’s quite common for a professor and/or colleague to request that I run an assessment and diagnostic examination upon some of their cases, so that they can have an “outside” verification of their findings.

However, when I received this request I shuddered knowing full well that there will be some very serious problems and most likely, mistakes.


The Sociopath Next Door

Quote:

Imagine – if you can – not having a conscience, none at all, no feelings of guilt or remorse no matter what you do, no limiting sense of concern for the well-being of strangers, friends, or even family members. Imagine no struggles with shame, not a single one in your whole life, no matter what kind of selfish, lazy, harmful, or immoral action you had taken. And pretend that the concept of responsibility is unknown to you, except as a burden others seem to accept without question, like gullible fools. Now add to this strange fantasy the ability to conceal from other people that your psychological makeup is radically different from theirs. Since everyone simply assumes that conscience is universal among human beings, hiding the fact that you are conscience-free is nearly effortless. You are not held back from any of your desires by guilt or shame, and others never confront you for your cold-bloodedness. The ice water in your veins is so bizarre, so completely outside of their personal experience, which they seldom even guess at your condition. ……In other words, you are completely free of internal restraints, and your unhampered liberty to do just as you please, with no pangs of conscience, is conveniently invisible to the world. You can do anything at all, and still your strange advantage over the majority of people, who are kept in line by their consciences, will most likely remain undiscovered. (Stout, 2005, pp. 1-2)


The amounts of people I know from within my clinical practice that can actually cause harm without remorse are numerous, so I often ponder the quantity of these violators who are “out there” in direct proportion with what and whom I do know.

“Hiding the fact that you are conscience-free…and your unhampered liberty” allow you to do anything you want, or not. Being able to recognize and properly diagnose such pathologic people seems obvious, and I believe that if you are able to “listen” and “see” then your skills will only get better. But, this ability begins by entering into the process of self-examination for the rest of your life if you wish to be deeply aware of your environment and the people you engage with on a daily basis. How many people do we know who actually struggle with living the self-examined life?

However, getting back to the sociopath amongst us, I’m not convinced that the numbers of people who live by these anti-social / aggressive / passive-aggressive, characteristics are few rather I often see freedom being confused with a “conscience-free” licentiousness especially amongst the sexually active and the corporate financial elite. These are only two of the most obvious and blatant examples of “conscience-free” licentiousness, there are more.

Perhaps that is why my colleague was able to overlook the criminal intent of his patient because my colleague will often use people as a sexual object and sperm sponge, as a means to an end, without remorse hence his inability to “see” and “listen” to the sociopath in his presence since he is behaving like one. He also uses people as a commodity to fill his bank account, he charges excessively for his substandard medical and psychiatric services and “gadgets” that he sells while ruthlessly psychologically abusing his office staff.

I really don’t want to discuss my colleague’s former patient rather let’s refer to my colleague as: Larry, and take a quick glimpse into the life of other “Larrys” we may know.

Larry has a history of gouging his customers in business, and in his practice, by selling low-grade products and services at above standard prices. There’s an expression and it really fits Larry: “if you are holding a penny in your hand, he will do anything and everything to get it”, that really sums up what Larry is like in business. He’s ruthless with his employees and his concept of leadership is based upon an authoritarian-totalitarian model of subjugation. To be honest, it really isn’t fair to discuss Larry because he’s the most obvious socially disconnected target to focus on, what about the people who are more subtle? I think I’ll address a few of them in a later blog.

Nevertheless, Larry frequents many bars and he’s notorious for the overwhelming size of his genitals thus when he is in various public parks, online, or in a public bathroom, and when he exposes his “unit”, many Gay men will literally fall down upon their knees and worship the monstrous piece of throbbing flesh. Little do they know that (a) Larry has more diseases than a walk-in Sex Clinic, and (b) he doesn’t have remorse, guilt, shame or accountability as he spreads his diseases! Of course, the ongoing tragedy is that the spread of contagion is, ongoing.

On a side note, promiscuous behaviors really piss me off because he, and others just like him, have almost completely contaminated the dating pool. Then again, what would ever make me believe that this city’s dating pool and its ratio of people with incurable STDs, would be any different from another?

I like asking questions as I write because (a) I already have a good answer either through experience and/or a formal education, and (b) the questions allow my reader to practice self-examination, and hopefully become better aware of who they are, and their socio-psychological locality.

I often wonder, which came first, the sociopath or the socio-cultural fabric that made the social pathology? What carves this deep and yet strangely invisible dividing line across the human race? Why do some people not have a conscience? What causes sociopaths? Is it nature or nurture, or perhaps, both? Does one have to be predisposed at conception and environment regulates how it is expressed, or not? Is there a range value from one extreme to another? Are we looking at an elaborate puzzle consisting of environmental factors such as prenatal care, early affection-stimulation, nutrition, reward-punishment models, unconditional love, affection-deprivation, and/or even birth order?

Actually, I don’t believe that these questions are enough or sufficient; we should be asking more because people are complex bundles of genetic and learned codification.

Regardless, when I am conducting a psychiatric / psychological diagnostic interview I consider three basic criteria that I use as a standard to assess cogency, and they are:

1. can you reason

2. if not, can you follow reason

3. do you



I will boldly extend the invitation to my reader to first, think about the criteria in direct correlation with your own life, assuming that you know how to reason, and second, reflect upon how you have participated within other’s lives. Were you, and/or they, not being reasonable but they may have been coercive, and that’s not the use of reason and neither does coercion and manipulation denote reasonableness and cogency, however it does suggest that a script / method was being followed, and to what extent have you been participating within the social unit’s script?

Within Transactional Analysis (TA) such participation is regarded as a “play” or “game” that we all become involved but some of us choose NOT to “play” the “game” rather we choose to be rational rather than analytical / methodical. I have a respect for T.A. but I also see its limits. Regardless TA seems to be an excellent tool to help “perceive” both known and covert dynamics: TA is “a system of psychotherapy that analyzes personal relationships and interactions in terms of conflicting or complementary ego states that correspond to the roles of parent, child, and adult.”


Martha Stout (2005) explains in uncomplicated terms the mind and behaviors of a sociopath, and from my experience, regardless of the person’s age, time of day, you will find many online, in corporate offices, Church strata, and at bars, and various other locations. One of the serious questions that I will often ask is, will “this one” kill me?

I’m also aware that there are other forms of murder, soul-killers are just as lethal but they prolong the agony and the eventual death, and if you are into “that”, and if you value suffering, then go knock your socks off, enjoy the “game” but make sure to leave me out of it.

Here’s a brief news clip in direct correlation with the case study that is under my review. A man lived within our local Gay community up until the other day and he is a sociopath by definition. My colleague, Larry, while treating him for “minor neurotic tendencies” completely missed the fact that the patient not only had lethal intent but he acted upon them numerous times throughout the last ten years either by taking a pool cue to a restaurant while breaking the arms of several patrons, he also started a financial pyramid regarding the selling and buying of land, schemes that he was able to avoid detection from the law. Also, this patient is a sexual predator, he uses people as a commodity, and at work he will either cause physical violence or he will use you as a psychological hostage by holding various people for psychological ransom: he derives pleasure from your emotional agony, he even extorted money from friends and coworkers. The police have arrested this patient and hopefully he will be sent away for a very long time because there is no cure for this gentleman. For the reason that he is an obvious sociopathic case, I often wonder about the numerous other sociopaths who are online and “out there” who function unnoticed, and when will “they” strike, and “how”?

The patient I just described, and he was on our local news after his arrest for using a lethal weapon upon one of his neighbors is obvious, but now I’m thinking about my colleague “Larry”, again.

Even though Larry has numerous academic alphabets after his name and he practices out of several hospitals, he refuses even to try to do what an ethically virtuous person would do, because he has become convinced that justice, temperance, generosity, love, compassion and the like are of little or no value. Once more, it isn’t a surprise that Larry doesn’t diagnose sociopaths very well. However, I will seldom use the word “evil” but I would have to agree with Aristotle when he called such people (kakos, phaulos) evil.

When I look into Larry’s face, and the patient who has recently been arrested for hacking up a man with a machete, and others who financially, sexually, and psychologically prey upon us, I see evil. I see such a deep pathology for which there is no cure because they are incapable of having even a semblance of empathy for others thus their behaviors are just plain evil.

Then again, I know of several men who cannot recognize Larry for who he is because they are not living the self-examined life, and perhaps, they, too, are just as ill?

Remember what Aesop said, “birds of a feather, flock together”, well in this case, it seems to be true. Larry is driven by desires for domination and luxury, and although he is single-minded in his pursuit of these goals, he portrays them as deeply divided, because his desire for more and more, leaves him dissatisfied and full of self-hatred as he perpetuates this cycle amongst the people he associates, dines, and “plays” with. Now, I’m beginning to sweat because I know of several people who have described Larry as being: loving, kind, affectionate, sane, trustworthy. Then again, given their personal histories, they wouldn’t know what a moral and rational man would look like, and I do not mean this to sound like arrogance, but these are the same people who shun my presence because “it hurts to look into my eyes”, and I've been accused of being "a mind reader, and he [I] is very disturbing to be around”, those are only a few quotes that have been used to describe what it’s like to “be around me”. Upon seeing me, Larry’s friends’ and supporters’ blood will often curdle, much like a vampire to sunrise!

It is my belief that Larry, and people who are just like him, not only have moral deficiencies but there are deep within their very fabric of “being” a complete lack of internal harmony that seems to be involved in nearly everything that they do. They cannot, and they do not, empathize. Ranging from the extreme sociopath to the moderate, here’s a quick list to watch for, they value:

objectification of another person rather than identification / respect / having a regard

chaos more than harmony

deceit more than truth

disorder more than stability

confusion more than understanding

at risk behaviors in sex and at work rather than “that” which is safe for he and his family

control / power / dominance rather than serving / helping / relieving pain

ranging from both extremes of being invincible to the unprotected, rather than providing a secure base

usurping their will OVER yours

ignorance more than intelligence and wisdom

punishment rather than reward

spiteful and heartless rather than affection and love

exclusion more than inclusion

depreciative more than appreciative

being emotionally undisciplined rather than reason

and unless they can replicate their inner world of distractions and commotion (drama-trauma) they are not content

Actually, being content would be my lowest goal regarding mental health since they wouldn’t know “happy” if it was a tree and fell on them hence they settle for just being content. There are many other clusters of characteristics that I can list, but I'm sure you get the "idea"!

Are we looking at a medical condition similar to discussing someone’s inability to distinguish colors? To what extent will we allow or tolerate the sociopath? Do we have limits or not? At what time do we intervene and punish the sociopath for not being able to see various colors? Do we have the ability to maintain a healthy boundary and to know our own limits?

I believe that there is much that we have to think about as we get to know our sense of “Self” and what constitutes sociopathic behaviors.


Aristotle didn’t have access to the Social Sciences as we know them especially when he wrote about the “evil person”, through “His desires for pleasure, power or some other external goal have become so strong that they make him care too little or not at all about acting ethically” (1166b5-29). This is why I am in full agreement with Aristotle. I believe that we must be mindful of our own psychological habits because “habits” dictate behavior. Habits, and the repetition of our thoughts, emotions and behaviors are the result of our values, and if we are not examining “what” and “how” we value, then our behaviors will habitually reflect “that”.

Therefore, to keep destructive inner forces in check, we need to develop the proper hygienic psychological habits and emotional responses not only when we are children, but also to reflect intelligently on our aims when we are adults.

I encourage everyone to do as Aristotle suggested, find a moral and ethical man, and learn, imitate, he and his behaviors, and before you know it, you too have become rational and moral.

As for my colleague Larry, his disruptive psychological forces will always be present; that is why even a good political and social community needs laws and the threat of punishment to manage the sociopath amongst us because they don't understand boundaries and neither do they recognize them. To the sociopath amongst us, you are their food!

Leaving the Nature/Nurture argument behind, this much I do know, for many of us who have escaped from either horribly pathologic families, neurotic systems or/and sick relationships, then clear thinking about the best goals of human life and the proper way to put them into practice is a rare achievement without some help, because the human psyche when formed under sadistic conditions is not always a hospitable environment for the development of these insights unless we are willing to do the interior work of self-examination. Especially, and I’ll repeat myself, when we are the product of grotesque family and social systems, and until we begin to reason and dialogue with someone rational and moral, then we will continue to replicate pathology.

NOTE: We also have institutions to protect the pathologic offender from offending, and people to help the offended to recover, and let’s not forget that with enough brain candies for the irreversible maniac who acts out of his/her lethal intent, the best we can do is to offer management, and hopefully a remedy, but the cure requires to work within potential. I seriously doubt if extreme sociopaths have the potential for a cure.

But, if we are looking for a cure, then how does one lead a horse to water? How do we get the horse to drink? How do we explain to the horse the distinction between swamp water and clean water? First, we begin with its thirst and hopefully then, the horse is willing to be taught!




No comments:

Followers